Re:Food Prices Are Soaring Faster Than Inflation and Incomes
by throwawaygh on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @12:27AM
(#26395708)
I think the thing you're missing is that affordable starter housing allows people to both meet a basic need and also make an investment.
Consider three people, p1, p2, p3.
P1: works at job making $X and rents home entire life.
P2: works at identical job making identical $X and buys + pays off identical home.
P3: works at identical job making identical $X and buys + misses 10 mortgage payments on identical home.
P1 is WAY better off than P2 or P3. Literally, the difference between retiring and working until you die.
"can afford down-payment and also has enough stability to never miss payments" induces a VERY extreme nonlinearity in outcomes that CPI very much fails to capture.
I don't think anything you've said in this thread even comes remotely close to acknowledging the reality that over half of America lives every day.
1. the part of a house that's getting expensive isn't the house itself, it's the land. the multi-million dollar homes in san francisco would only be worth a few hundred thousand tops if they were moved to rural idaho.
2. corporations fall part too. more specifically, their physical assets (eg. machines in factories) fall apart. In both cases they're kept up by routine maintenance. The only difference is that in a corporation the maintenance is paid from revenue before profits/dividends are paid out, whereas in a house the maintenance is paid out of pocket by the owner.
3. it's not a question of deprecation. after you eat a piece of bread it's gone. that's not due to depreciation, it's due to you consuming it.
>I clearly say at the end that if CPI is not measuring these price increases we should use a different measure. I'm not sure you understand what's going on in this conversation, but food is in the CPI.
That's my original point. Rent (and imputed rent) is directly measured in the CPI, so there's no need to measure home prices.