News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by oarsinsync on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:15AM (#26376430)
What’s a digital currency without mining, and how does it differ from regular fiat money today?
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by TacticalCoder on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:28AM (#26376558)
> What’s a digital currency without mining...

I take it GP meant mining without gigantic electricity consumption: so not proof-of-stake but proof-of-work

> ... and how does it differ from regular fiat money today?

There was a discussion here a few days ago where people were trying to determine how many swiss bills were circulating... Someone commented on the irony, in a thread hating on cryptocurrencies, that anyone at anytime can know exactly how many, say, Bitcoin or Ethereum do actually exists.

There are other difference between government issued money and cryptocurrencies: for example some cryptocurrencies have a fixed, carved in stone, supply curve and so you can know beforehand exactly how many are going to be mined each year.

This is quite different, for example, from Venezuela's bolivar: Maduro just announced that 1 000 0000 bolivian bills were going to be printed now.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by yardstick on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:53AM (#26376812)
> that anyone at anytime can know exactly how many, say, Bitcoin or Ethereum do actually exists.

Isn’t there a distinction between issued/minted currency and the amount in circulation? With Bitcoin and physical cash you know how many coins are minted and notes issued etc.

But how much of that is in circulation? Does lost physical currency still qualify as in circulation? What about Bitcoin wallets long lost by their owners (such as the British man who keeps wanting a rubbish dump to search for a HDD he threw out years ago, or the person who forgot his password and has 2 attempts left until the wallet self destructs). I don’t think either currency can accurately track the amount in circulation.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by maxerickson on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:08AM (#26376958)
The blockchain provides a complete record of the movement of bitcoins. So for a given address, you can see how long value has been there, and the addresses that participated in the send transaction, and so on. You can't from there figure out how many coins are still available for circulation, but you can see how much has moved (or hasn't moved) over any period of time (last day, last week, last year, etc). From there you can define circulation statistics, like 'value that hasn't moved in 3 years' or whatever.

For paper money, the fraction that gets destroyed is probably small enough to not matter.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by gruez on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:09AM (#26376964)
>physical cash you know how many coins are minted and notes issued etc.

but with coins/cash the actual circulation can exceed what the government claims to have issued, through counterfeits or malfeasance (ie. the government under-reporting the issuance).

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by petre on Sunday March 07, 2021 @02:00PM (#26378642)
There are cryptocurrencies with inflation like PeerCoin. Unfortunately it's also mined.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by ChainOfFools on Sunday March 07, 2021 @09:36PM (#26381826)
the network is also barely functional these days. resyncing is so slow its hardly worth running a node. oh also pretty sure PPC is proof of stake, it was the first widely traded (maybe first, period?) crypto to implement PoS.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by SkipperCat on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:28AM (#26376557)
I don't think there is any difference. When the Federal Reserve purchases securities in the markets, they do it by just "creating" money. I think they literally just type in a number into a computer and use those newly created funds.

You could do this in any centrally digitally managed currency too. You could probably do it with a blockchain currency too if you get enough people to agree to the change.

Of course, if you don't like this, there's always the gold standard.....

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by gruez on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:42AM (#26376698)
>I don't think there is any difference. [...]

> You could probably do it with a blockchain currency too if you get enough people to agree to the change.

That's a huge difference. The fed can print money whenever they want, whereas with bitcoin they need to convince a supermajority of the miners and users, otherwise they end up with a forked chain like bitcoin cash/gold/sv.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by gruez on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:25AM (#26376518)
Presumably he's talking about proof of stake. It's not a prefect replacement for proof of work, but it's also less centralized than the current fiat system.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by analog31 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:46AM (#26376737)
From what I've read, mining makes digital currency subject to control by governments that can subsidize or even monopolize the mining process. So a mining-free currency might be closer to the dream of a currency that is not subject to government manipulation. That's assuming a different technology doesn't just expose a different hack.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by gruez on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:51AM (#26376800)
>From what I've read, mining makes digital currency subject to control by governments that can subsidize or even monopolize the mining process.

If governments can subsidize the mining process, can't they also subsidize the staking process?

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by analog31 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:28AM (#26377175)
Probably. I'm guessing that a currency that's permanently free from government interference is a pipe dream. Or perhaps more likely, a cat and mouse game like trying to keep a computer system from getting hacked. Each currency will have a honeymoon period before people figure out how to corrupt it, so the solution may be to live with a constant evolution of currencies.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by dfrankow on Sunday March 07, 2021 @05:38PM (#26380478)
I think Nano just handed out a fixed amount of tokens through captchas. Now no more will ever be created, but they can still be transferred.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by feawwefawefa on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:25AM (#26376520)
people on HN like to whine about the environment. they love the statistic that bitcoin uses more energy than argentina. ask them 6 months ago (when bitcoin still used the same amount of energy as argentina) and they will tell you how much they love btc and decentralization.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by whoknew1122 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:31AM (#26376585)
It's almost as if people's thoughts can change and evolve.

I honestly wonder when and how changing your mind became a bad thing.

Show me someone whose thoughts or ideas don't evolve and I'll show you someone who's wasting their life.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by virtue3 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @10:50AM (#26376782)
I suspect a lot of people didn't realize how much power was being used for bitcoin.

New information should ideally get people to re-evaluate their initial opinions about something (ideally).

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by cesarb on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:01PM (#26377489)
> I suspect a lot of people didn't realize how much power was being used for bitcoin.

And another thing which changed is that, every time the price of Bitcoin increases, it can (and will) use more power (the amount of power a Bitcoin miner uses is limited by how much power it can buy with the mining rewards, because if it used more power than that, it would be mining at a loss). There's a lot of difference between when one Bitcoin was USD 1, when it was USD 4000, and now that it's over USD 50000. Someone who was OK with how much power the Bitcoin network used back when the per-block mining reward was around USD 50, might not be OK with how much power the Bitcoin network uses now that the per-block mining reward is over USD 325000.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by ravenstine on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:16AM (#26377049)
Could be that, and it can also be that people are capable of being massive hypocrites. Nobody who opposes Bitcoin on environmental grounds has anything to say about the sheer waste and pollution that most of us take part in. If Bitcoin is so bad for using as much energy as Argentina, then we should stop using energy to stream entertainment, which we are doing now more than ever.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by whoknew1122 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:17PM (#26377615)
> "Nobody who opposes Bitcoin on environmental grounds has anything to say about the sheer waste and pollution that most of us take part in."

[citation needed]

> "If Bitcoin is so bad for using as much energy as Argentina, then we should stop using energy to stream entertainment, which we are doing now more than ever."

Until we get off fossil-fuel based electricity, all environmental arguments are going to be based off marginal utility. There's a trade-off.

I personally think that Bitcoin at best is an unregulated financial market and at worst fake internet money. The fact mining contributes to more energy consumption than entire countries is worrying to me. It's a problem that's only going to get worse.

On the other hand, let's look at your argument about streaming entertainment. Currently plugged into my house, I have 2 TVs and 4 computer monitors. I use these to stream entertainment (among other things). Is it wasteful? Yeah, but entertainment is necessary for a balanced life and mental well-being.

Are my 6 screens wasteful? To some extent, although most of that waste is a byproduct of manufacturing where the 'off' button doesn't turn my screens off; it just puts then in a sleep mode which consumes power. So all 6 screens consume some amount of electricity 24 hours a day. This is a problem which should be fixed.

This is a problem with most modern appliances. It contributes to enough excess energy consumption that it even has its own name--vampire electricity.

You see? People can have critiques of both at the same time. But even if you take all the vampire electricity my appliances consume, it's still a drop in the bucket compared with what it takes to mine fake internet money.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by websites2323 on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:30PM (#26377746)
Hi, I oppose bitcoin and have lots to say about the sheer waste and pollution that most of us take part in.

I also put my money where my mouth is! I drive electric and charge only at my employer, which uses 100% solar. I don’t eat meat. I shop at package free groceries. I eat as much local food as possible. I don’t stream movies or music.

We exist, my friend, but that’s besides the point. There are no saints in systems as complex as energy. You can only take aim at the big stuff and hope you can make an impact.

Bitcoin is entirely unnecessary, unlike eating and driving. Participating is a choice. And it’s a bad choice.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by UncleMeat on Sunday March 07, 2021 @02:08PM (#26378735)
Hi there. Huge critic of BTC emissions here. I give a tremendous amount of money annually to nonprofits seeking to curb global emissions.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by aww_dang on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:18AM (#26377070)
Personally, I am of the opinion that individuals should be able to use electricity however they choose, provided they pay a market rate for it. Interesting to see HN praising the CCP's policies in this regard.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by sudosysgen on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:40PM (#26377852)
There is no market rate for electricity in any reasonable country. Electric generation is one of these things the free market doesn't do well, so the vast majority of electricity markets are either completely state operated (as in Canada, much of Europe, China, etc...), or highly subsidized.

The first is way more efficient and allows for much lower electricity rates, and the second is the only way to get the economics right to allow for growth.

That comes inevitably with regulatory restrictions on what you can do and how you can do it. Forbidding people using coal power to mine bitcoin is more than reasonable and indeed typical as far as energy use regulations go.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by 8note on Sunday March 07, 2021 @01:39PM (#26378398)
They should be paying me for the increased carbon dioxide they're putting in my air though
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by blululu on Sunday March 07, 2021 @11:39AM (#26377286)
Market rates for electricity do not exist in a country where the power grid is controlled by communists. Given that most countries subsidize electricity consumption the same basic issue applies. Looking beyond naive libertarianism, there is the bigger question of waste and whether people are entitled to consume a resource regardless of the application. Historically efficiency was seen as a virtue, but modern attitudes are more open to waste. It’s a fair question to ask whether this is an aberration.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by aww_dang on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:11PM (#26377570)
>Market rates for electricity do not exist in a country where the power grid is controlled by communists. Given that most countries subsidize electricity consumption the same basic issue applies.

Yes, that's a problem in my view. Observing that it is the status quo doesn't rationalize it or further prohibitions to defend price controls.

I'm not sure if you would regard it as naive, but price controls are widely regarded as inefficient distortions of a market.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_controls#Criticism

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by sudosysgen on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:43PM (#26377882)
I live in Québec. We have state run electricty, which turns a profit and isn't subsidized. It's by far the cheapest in North America, and the essentially the cheapest unsubsidized energy in the world. The grid is also 99.9% renewable (everywhere except for some islands)

So the idea that price controls and nationalization somehow causes inefficiency in this case is just a tale economists tell themselves. In the real world, all of the most successful energy grids use those tools.

In other words, you're arguing against reality.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by aww_dang on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:52PM (#26377950)
If Quebec is running a profitable business, there's no argument in what I wrote?

The most I could say is that there may be unseen costs of nationalization. I.e. it could be cheaper still if privatized, but that is further afield from the discussion. In HN parlance I suppose I could demand that you provide evidence and sources proving the same power stations wouldn't operate more efficiently under private ownership, but I don't think that would be fair or friendly.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by 8note on Sunday March 07, 2021 @01:42PM (#26378432)
Profitable for the province is different from profitable for a business.

Even if hydro itself isn't making more revenue than its direct costs, if it increases the tax revenues for the government by better uses of the electricity, the government is still making a profit

There are unseen benefits to nationalization too, not just costs

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by sudosysgen on Sunday March 07, 2021 @03:16PM (#26379380)
Replying due to edit : you can claim that a free market could be cheaper. But there are free energy markets right next to Quebec, and costs are around twice as high, so you are arguing against reality.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by aww_dang on Monday March 08, 2021 @09:28AM (#26386100)
That's playing a bit fast and loose with the definition of "free market". Hydropower is also geographically unique.
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by sudosysgen on Monday March 08, 2021 @04:04PM (#26391525)
Hydropower is not geographically unique, there are many US states (and Chinese provinces) which use mainly hydropower.

If you think that I am overextending the term free market, then you must agree that there are no energy free markets? There are two options here. Either there are, and they are all suboptimal to at least some state run solutions, or they don't exist, in which case my argument still applies.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by aww_dang on Tuesday March 09, 2021 @01:53AM (#26396163)
>Hydropower is not geographically unique

Yes, many places have hydropower. Some have more than others. There are also population, consumption concerns relative to the supply. The Wikipedia article notes that the Quebecois authorities subsidize aluminum smelters with a goal of job creation. Perhaps the market price could be even cheaper without this subsidy?

Electricity markets are generally highly regulated, public-private partnerships or outright nationalized. I don't see a dispute here or an argument.

Observing that something is commonplace isn't a rationalization of the efficiency or morality of the practice.

>you are arguing against reality.

This isn't helpful. Different individuals have different observations, experiences, perceptions and thus opinions. That's healthy. It is the source of discussion. Would it be helpful if I characterized this turn of phrase as you arguing for an exclusive license on "reality"?

No, I don't think that would advance the discussion at all, but it would be equivalent to what you've offered in my view.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by sudosysgen on Sunday March 07, 2021 @12:55PM (#26377976)
There is no market. It has a monopoly, and there are things you aren't allowed to do with the energy.

It's not a business, either.

Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by aww_dang on Sunday March 07, 2021 @01:03PM (#26378065)
Re:China’s Bitcoin miners flee Inner Mongolia ahead of crypt... by sudosysgen on Sunday March 07, 2021 @03:15PM (#26379365)
There is no Quebec market for energy. What you're reading is someone trying to fit the style distinction local market/export market.

But Hydro Quebec has a total monopoly and zero competition in Quebec, by law. It's not a market.