Gift card retailers get most or all of the standard 30% cut, as I understand it, leaving Apple with nothing. If that's true there's no way for Apple to withhold less than 30% without either breaking their unified payment system or losing money on each sale. Taking the loss would expose them to massive fraud from collusion between app vendors and retailers.
Charging a lower rate for some categories (like News Stand content) without risking losses from gift card arbitrage would mean creating another payment tier where gift card balances didn't work, complicating the model.
Can someone with knowledge of the situation confirm whether this is accurate?
This also shows where retailers can be confusing (to me): it takes labor to ship, display, and activate those cards (activation can be a huge pain) but that's all considered fixed overhead I suppose.
My sole means of paying for iTunes purchases is via giftcards because they can always be obtained for a discount of between 20-25% if you look. A retailer here was recently offering them at buy 2 get 1 free, or 33% discount.
If I use my own subscription system, own payment system, own user system, and my own bandwidth to supply the content, then I shouldn't have to give anything to Apple. I don't need to send a fee to Microsoft if I have software that delivers content in the same way. That Apple thinks they are entitled to anything in this regard is absurd.
How are they not entitled to something?
You wouldn't have the customers if they hadn't provided the market place.
Basically Apple is like a giant cruise ship company that can stop at any of thousands of islands along it's way. The islands that don't want to follow their rules (give us 30% of your bananas, don't use our private radio channel, wear some pants for god's sake, etc.) well that's their prerogative but they won't be able to sell their wares to Apple's thousands of well heeled tourists.
As if you could offend The Creator, who made humans[1] pantsless, by not wearing pants.
[1] source: a creation story
Because Apple's in-app purchases don't distinguish between features and content, Apple can't use different pricing schemes.
I think Apple may try to change this situation with their News Stand system in iOS5. The content appearing there are still normal apps, they're just grouped together in a special folder and feature automatic downloads.
My guess is that content purchased in those News Stand apps will be less taxed than other in-app purchases, for example just 10%. That way Apple will keep some of their most important 'partners' happy.