"whether you wouldn't be better off for purely selfish reason if you gave up on project management and idk wrote some scuba software"
It's selfish to assume that because you might be happy doing that, then all people should do that. Maybe he wants to work on Linux? Nobody is forced to contribute to or work on his project.
> But if someone who 100% knew better did something they shouldn’t have, sometimes getting chewed out is appropriate.
I don't think this is unqualifiedly the case, and I very much don't think this is the case in a situation where a hapless stranger's transgressions only go as far as wasting five minutes of your time by making an unacceptable pull request.