Re:Ask HN: Do you think Agile/Scrum is beneficial for softwa...
by haswell on Friday March 05, 2021 @09:41AM
(#26357325)
You’re offering criticisms of what OP is trying to do, but you have not offered an alternative. What is your solution?
Thus far, your position on this is too rigid and does not account for the spectrum of: org size, type, age, etc. It lacks maturity and awareness of the realities of many organizations.
If you’ve found a place where you can implement this stance: great! The vast majority of people are not in that position, and criticizing them for it is not a great look.
Re:Ask HN: Do you think Agile/Scrum is beneficial for softwa...
by carmen_sandiego on Sunday March 07, 2021 @05:17AM
(#26374699)
The vast majority of software engineers can’t change employer?
Re:Ask HN: Do you think Agile/Scrum is beneficial for softwa...
by haswell on Sunday March 07, 2021 @09:51PM
(#26381890)
No, this is obviously not what I said. Nor is changing employers automatically better. There are (as I suspect you already know) a myriad of factors involved in choosing an employer and choosing to leave.
The implication that this is “the solution” is pretty naive.
What I am saying is that using Scrum to paper over a dysfunctional organization merely adds more dysfunction. It's a bit like the old joke: you have a problem, you adopt XML as the solution, now you have two problems. If you have a dysfunctional organization, then you either fix that if it's in your power, grin and bear it if you can't, or leave if that's an option. You're not going to fix it with Scrum (or for that matter, Kanban or any other off-the-shelf process).