News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by trident5000 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:48AM (#26342325)
You could make up some fear mongering "study" about almost every energy using topic. AI and video rendering for instance which is often for some marginal purpose. Or heating pools, idle electronics, big homes with AC, leisure travel, all the useless crap bought and manufactured in China with dirty coal, etc.
Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by GavinMcG on Thursday March 04, 2021 @09:07AM (#26342607)
Are you saying we shouldn't understand the consequences of what we do?

It's useful to know that BTC has major externalities because it allows us to make a rational choice. We could make different choices about all the things you listed, too. Or not! But you seem to be actually arguing for willful blindness, here.

Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by effie on Thursday March 04, 2021 @01:24PM (#26346109)
You are misunderstanding the point. Of course, cryptocurrencies have externalities and it is good to quantify them. In that respect, the paper could be useful. The objection is, this paper makes no attempt to analyze and show cryptocurrencies are worth attention any more than other 1000 consumer classes. It just states "crypto has externalities", does not weight them properly in perspective and advocates for "more research" and "lets regulate". That is irresponsible. Regulation should happen at the biggest most important polluters such as transport and coal plants.
Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by GavinMcG on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:22PM (#26346906)
It's a single paper. It responsibly limits itself to a manageable conclusion and responsibly points out where there are still open questions.

Can you point out where in the paper the authors leap to "let's regulate" as you put it? There seems to be one small section about regulation, but it doesn't exactly advocate for it: it describes how their pricing research could be used in regulation. It describes challenges in regulating. But it responsibly avoids making moral/policy claims.

Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by effie on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:25PM (#26348580)
The whole paper shows implicit interest in taxing/regulating cryptocurrency mining instead of unbiased dispassionate scientific analysis. You can see this explicitly in the last section, starting with

> However, the ability to locate, and re-locate, cryptomining almost anywhere (e.g., following the cheapest, under-regulated electricity source) and fund mining camps from anywhere with complete or near anonymity create significant challenges to implementing effective regulation

Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by GavinMcG on Thursday March 04, 2021 @05:06PM (#26349096)
Do you think a discussion of policy implications should somehow ignore relevant policy considerations?

It's helpful for authors to point out how they think their work fits into the broader scheme of things. They correctly identify that a high cost to benefit ratio might make people interested in regulating it; they also correctly identify that practical concerns make that difficult. There is no advocacy there.

Even if there were, it wouldn't be inappropriate to say "hey, there's a downside to this; we recommend trying to fix that."

Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by trident5000 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @09:14AM (#26342708)
aRE yOu SayInG tHat

No Im actually not. You said that. Pointing out that you can cherry pick and micro-analyze anything.

Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by GavinMcG on Thursday March 04, 2021 @09:25AM (#26342826)
It was a question. You seemed to be implying that any such study would be "fear-mongering" (your words). That suggests that you think the studies wouldn't be useful and that we shouldn't do them.

Your playground rhetoric isn't helpful.

Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by jf22 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:50AM (#26342350)
Right, and all those things are harmful to the planet.
Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by pseudo0 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @09:55AM (#26343165)
Making the study about bitcoin in particular seems like a clickbaity way of getting attention, when the core issue seems to be dirty power generation. Bitcoin makes up a tiny fraction of non-essential American power usage, so focusing on it in particular just seems like jumping on the "Bitcoin is terrible for the environment" bandwagon. Articles on this topic seem to pop up every couple weeks on HN lately, and they generally aren't novel or interesting.
Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by jtkgkgnyn on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:57AM (#26342445)
Human life in general is harmful to the planet.

So what are you saying?

Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by jf22 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @09:02AM (#26342513)
I don't understand why you would feel as though this reply says anything. There is always something worse or has alternative consequences.
Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by unfamiliar on Thursday March 04, 2021 @09:07AM (#26342606)
That it's important to measure the impact of each accurately so that we can make sensible decisions about where to curtail said damages.
Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by trident5000 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:51AM (#26342363)
Many I just listed use more energy than btc...so yes, they are.
Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by pwinnski on Thursday March 04, 2021 @11:46AM (#26344709)
You mentioned five things, all of which are frequently focused on as contributors to global climate change. Well, I'm not sure I've seen "AI and video rendering" mentioned in that context, but I'm also not sure that they use more power than crypto mining. But definitely I've seen articles addressing idle electronics[0], big homes with AC[1], leisure travel[2], and "all the useless crap bought and manufactured in China with dirty coal"[3].

So it shouldn't be surprising that crypto mining is added to the list.

Any and all heavy users of energy are contributing to climate change in some way, and the cost/benefit analysis for some are more justifiable than others. Food production is energy-hungry, but without it, people die. Nobody would die if crypto mining ended tomorrow. Thanks to government standards, idle electronics are better now than they were, and will continue to improve in the future. Big homes with A/C is a largely American problem without anything to really address it yet, but there has been a lot of attention focused on the issue already.

In general a bad thing is bad whether there are worse things or not. Crypto mining is a big drain on energy resources with very little benefit, or with benefit to very few people, and it doesn't have to the biggest drain, or benefit the fewest number of people the least for that to be true.

0. https://www.nrdc.org/stories/keep-your-devices-wasting-energ...

1. https://www.ajc.com/news/local/are-air-conditioners-slowly-k...

2. https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/7/25/8881364/greta-th...

3. https://phys.org/news/2017-11-impact-climate-china-substanti...

Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by effie on Thursday March 04, 2021 @01:29PM (#26346172)
By endlessly arguing about regulating minor consumer/production classes the attention span and opportunities for effective change diminish. The regulation should happen for the big polluters first, i.e. coal plants, transport ships. When that is done and the problem is largely fixed, you can spend your time arguing about cryptocurrency taxation, why not.

It makes no sense, in the current situation, to discuss 10000 small energy consumers and appropriate pollution tax for all of them. We need to fix the damn energy production first.

Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by jf22 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @09:03AM (#26342536)
So what are you saying, that because other things are also bad we can't have a discussion how bad one thing is?
Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by trident5000 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @09:07AM (#26342598)
Im saying you were being sarcastic thereby making the claim that those things are not harmful, and they are. Im not sure whats confusing here.
Re:Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and... by jf22 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @10:08AM (#26343322)
I was not being sarcastic. Those things are harmful.