News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by drieddust on Thursday March 04, 2021 @01:48AM (#26339410)
Your argument will hold true if social media companies act as a platform and don't censor or intervene.

In reality they take sides and push their agenda so this is bound to happen. Companies coming together to de-platform Trump and Twitter CEO admitting that twitter employees are left leaning are very good examples of why this would happen.

Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by addicted on Thursday March 04, 2021 @06:40AM (#26341201)
We saw what happens when employees are right leaning in the US. Their CEO gets kicked out and has his stock options stripped.

In the US if you have a non left leaning company that’s a bad thing because in the US the center is so far right that the majority of left leaning people look wildly right wing from a European perspective (which is where the right left view of politics comes from), and the majority of the people on the right are either delusional or scamming.

Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by revendell_elf on Thursday March 04, 2021 @01:51AM (#26339424)
But those are the "experts" from the West. They believe that censoring Trump was correct but a country who wants to save it's sovereignty is incorrect and should not happen. It goes against their narrative.
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by drieddust on Thursday March 04, 2021 @01:58AM (#26339468)
Champions of free expression wants to grant more power to Jack and his cohort than to the democratically elected Government because Governments are corrupt but Jack is not. How Ironic?
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by bongoman37 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:57AM (#26340574)
India's government is only nominally democratic and rapidly falling in freedom parameters looked at from any perspective. They are charging climate activists with sedition, holding protestors without charge for months, increase in extrajudicial killings and rapidly falling Human Development Indicators.
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by revendell_elf on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:11AM (#26341382)
Please cite your source for all these claims. I'm pretty sure I'm lagging behind in the news these days.
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by bongoman37 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:38AM (#26342189)
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by yuriko_boyko on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:56AM (#26339851)
Their manifesto did not say that they'll regulate social media and try to limit internet freedoms. They were not elected for that. Can any future election be truly democratic if those in power get to issue content takedowns?
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by drieddust on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:19AM (#26341946)
An absurd argument. If a new situation emerges Government should not act because it was not in their manifesto?
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by creata on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:45AM (#26339786)
Yes, I want Jack Dorsey, CEO of Twitter, to have more control over Twitter than the government.

> the democratically elected Government

The democratically elected government was elected for a million different reasons, but their proficiency at managing social media networks was not one of them. And, you know, controlling every single social network is just a bit more dangerous than controlling one.

[dead]
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by creata on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:31AM (#26339699)
Be a bit more generous in your interpretation of others' comments. Looking at the commenter's post history, it's pretty clear that they're talking about the Indian government.
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by s3tz on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:05AM (#26339512)
Don't think anybody was thinking about race here. More like taking aim at the political do gooder class.
[dead]
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by rishav_sharan on Thursday March 04, 2021 @02:49AM (#26339811)
As someone who understands Hindi, yeah I have to concur it's a authoritarian and stupid law. It will only be selectively enforced and seeing the track record of this regime, it will be used to suppress dissent.
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by _bsn2 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:22AM (#26340018)
As someone who understands English as well, yeah, I have to concur that social media giants like Twitter have gotten more powerful than necessary. The law is just right, and at the right time, nothing stupid about it.
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by addicted on Thursday March 04, 2021 @06:41AM (#26341211)
Except the law does nothing to restrict social media companies and everything to restrict people on social media.

Someone upstream made a ridiculous comparison to Donald Trump, whose Twitter was shut down because he had just incited violence.

Well that was the extent of what was or could be done to him.

With this law, and the way the current Indian government acts, your Twitter shutting down would be the least of your worries. The government would send its goons in uniform to arrest you, probably illegally (the way the 20 year old activist was illegally arrested, then illegally transported to a different state by the police so she could be denied bail in a friendlier jurisdiction), denied bail for months at end, unless they are the lucky few whose bail application reaches a higher court, which hasn’t been as ridiculous as the lower courts yet, beaten up, have the internet cut off, etc.

The current Indian government deserves absolutely no benefit of doubt because they continue to enact anti democratic measures, while destroying the economy, even though they were lectured solely on promises of improving the economy (their destruction of the economy began well before the pandemic...Dec 2016 to be precise...just look at a GDP growth chart and it peaks in Dec 2016 and makes an abrupt turn going from increasing growth to decreasing growth right then. Anyone with a passing knowledge of India knows which disastrous, and completely politically motivated decision ruined the futures of hundreds of millions of people).

Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by _bsn2 on Friday March 05, 2021 @01:58AM (#26353703)
Not really. The law is not about restricting anyone, but rather about making media houses more accountable by making them store information (for a limited time) regarding the content publishers and furnishing it when requested within that time frame.

That 20 year old activist (Disha Ravi) you refer was arrested because she was clearly involved (via the document shared by Greta Thunberg) in seditious activity towards the sovereign state of India, nothing illegal or unethical about that I guess! She was carted off to a different state because the outcome of her illicit activities could have led to more violence in that other state hence it would be apt that she face the courts within that state's jurisdiction.

There has been not a single incident of anti-democratic measure from the current Indian government, it would be more than interesting if you could provide rational, logical and judicially verifiable information to counter that.

From your tone and attitude, it looks like you have some kind of unwarranted grudge against the current government, most probably because you are a crony of the Congress who's sitting in the opposition, playing every game possible to topple the good natured environment created by the currently in power BJP government.

Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by tejasgarde on Thursday March 04, 2021 @03:32AM (#26340080)
Agree Social media platforms gotten more powerful than necessary. Also Saying new laws are suppressing freedom of speech is not enough , for sake of valid argument one must point out which clause/sub clause of the said law mentions this suppression.
Re:India’s new intermediary liability and digital media laws... by _bsn2 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @04:08AM (#26340277)
I am not at all of the opinion that the new laws suppress freedom of speech. I was countering the previous comment using sarcasm as a means to convey the futility of their argument.