Re:Killing TurboTax
by sokoloff on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:38PM
(#26335805)
There are scenarios in tax planning where expert advice can change the tax you owe by getting you to do something slightly different.
If you bunch deductions, you might alternate between the standard deduction and itemizing deductions, meaning if you want to support charities with $10K per year, you're better off to donate in Jan and Dec of the same year (itemizing), then skip 13 months (taking the standard deduction), then donate twice in the year after that (itemizing), etc. With the increased standard deduction, this may be needed to allow your donations to become deductible at all.
There are other planning strategies that a combined advisor and preparer can help with. (Using your HSA optimally as a retirement account. Optimizing your Roth conversions over the years. Modeling whether Backdoor Roth contributions make sense (or "what would you have to believe is true to have them make sense?") For business owners, setting the balance between your salary and distributions of profits.) Those are advice activities that overlap with a detailed understanding of your financial and tax situation and often mean that you have to change something about the structure or timing of your activity to accomplish your goal.
The IRS is in an OK position to look back and judge "based on what actually happened, here's what you owe", but in a terrible position to offer optimization advice.
If you bunch deductions, you might alternate between the standard deduction and itemizing deductions, meaning if you want to support charities with $10K per year, you're better off to donate in Jan and Dec of the same year (itemizing), then skip 13 months (taking the standard deduction), then donate twice in the year after that (itemizing), etc. With the increased standard deduction, this may be needed to allow your donations to become deductible at all.
There are other planning strategies that a combined advisor and preparer can help with. (Using your HSA optimally as a retirement account. Optimizing your Roth conversions over the years. Modeling whether Backdoor Roth contributions make sense (or "what would you have to believe is true to have them make sense?") For business owners, setting the balance between your salary and distributions of profits.) Those are advice activities that overlap with a detailed understanding of your financial and tax situation and often mean that you have to change something about the structure or timing of your activity to accomplish your goal.
The IRS is in an OK position to look back and judge "based on what actually happened, here's what you owe", but in a terrible position to offer optimization advice.