News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Index 2021 by bluecalm on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @03:21PM (#26333871)
It's strange that it came down to it. AI is a field inspired by our notion of human intelligence. Yet a human can learn to recognize road signs with a fraction of the data state of the art "AI" algorithms need these days. To play chess at the same level as a human master a state of the art neural network based engine needs data from tens of millions of self played games - several orders of magnitude more than a human master encounters (and then the computer has huge advantage in calculation speed and accuracy as well). I don't think deep learning is the end of it. It would be really great to see people venturing into different approaches. We can do much better than pattern recognition on huge amount of data.
Re:AI Index 2021 by superbcarrot on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @03:29PM (#26333959)
> several orders of magnitude more than a human master encounters

Not if you account for millions of years of evolution that got your nervous system to its current state and access to books and training materials which add up to multiple decades/centuries of precompiled and synthesised expertise from other people who learned chess in similar ways to you.

This is a minor point though. I agree that deep learning isn't it, or that if it is, that would be quite underwhelming.

Re:AI Index 2021 by mjburgess on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @04:48PM (#26335131)
Evolution produced the system, not the chess training. Humans aren't born able to play chess.

The relevant comparison is "training time spent on chess".

Re:AI Index 2021 by ad404b8a372f2b9 on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:49PM (#26335936)
If you want to compare today's state of the art chess playing model to a human that's the relevant comparison, but if you want to compare the current field of AI to humans the line between the system and the training becomes fuzzy. If you look at the past 10 years of AI we have massively reduced the amount of data required to achieve a given score for computer vision models by making changes to the system of the neural networks. In fact it's where most of the improvements have come from rather than increasing the amount of data. I don't see a reason to believe it won't keep working this way. I'd say we're being damn efficient and it doesn't feel fair to say "look at how much data they need, the approach is fundamentally wrong" when we've been at it for such a short amount of time compared to the millions of years it took humans to evolve.
Re:AI Index 2021 by Isinlor on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:51PM (#26335955)
Human designed chess, chess are made to be played by humans.

If you scramble all pixels in some game in a random, but fixed way, you will never learn to play it.

But speed of training of a simple feed forward network will not change at all.

Here you have somewhat simpler version of what I propose: https://high-level-4.herokuapp.com/experiment

Here is the paper: https://rach0012.github.io/humanRL_website/