Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality
by Twisol on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:02AM
(#26330163)
Another commenter linked this post by Scott Aaronson: https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=4021
The money quote (which leads a few more paragraphs on the details) is this:
> But, while I remain less than 100% satisfied about “why the complex numbers? why not just the reals?,” there’s one conclusion that my recent circling-back to these questions has made me fully confident about. Namely: quantum mechanics over the quaternions is a flaming garbage fire, which would’ve been rejected at an extremely early stage of God and the angels’ deliberations about how to construct our universe.
Re:Imaginary Numbers May Be Essential for Describing Reality
by phkahler on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @11:14AM
(#26330379)
But elegance is irrelevant. Imaginary numbers are a subset of the quaternions, just as reals are a subset of the imaginaries.
The proper question is not "do I like it" but is it necessary. The answer apparently is No for the quaternions.
The answer will have to grapple with both the philosophy of physics and the properties of these various fields.