News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by eqvinox on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @09:46AM (#26328961)
Of course it's part of the problem. But it's also a somewhat unavoidable side effect of supporting minorities.

In a very weird way, anti-discriminative behaviour itself needs to be discriminative, because it needs to support minorities. And rightfully so, there needs to be a positive bias for minorities who were historically disenfranchised. Otherwise the historical disadvantage will propagate itself further. But then when you look at firings like this, it becomes very hard to distinguish whether it's discrimination or rightful. These two are members of minority groups. Their firing is, rightfully, examined to fine detail. But that same magnification lens has that chilling effect for the decision of hiring minority members.

It's really a have-your-cake-and-eat-it problem. It f_cking sucks. And I don't know how to do better. I absolutely think we need affirmative action to relieve historic deficits, but at the same time this affirmative support is in itself discriminatory and can have negative effects. What to do? :(

Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by higerordermap on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:15AM (#26329355)
You know who is at the end disadvantaged by affirmative action? Minorities / women.

Even if a PoC / woman is actually talented, people will subconsciously perceive them as diversity hires.

There were plenty of instances of people telling on this forum that they don't want to be seen as diversity person, but actual engineer.

Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by xenihn on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:36AM (#26329711)
I think we've officially reached the point where you can stomp lumping all women together. Some companies are now prioritizing interns and junior devs from HBCUs, because they ended up with a new problem where the overwhelming majority of non-male hires for those roles were Asian.
Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by Veelox on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @03:05PM (#26333654)
>there needs to be a positive bias for minorities who were historically disenfranchised

>I absolutely think we need affirmative action to relieve historic deficits, but at the same time this affirmative support is in itself discriminatory and can have negative effects. What to do?

Quit affirmative action at anything above the high school level and poor resources into fixing the issues before high school. Personally I reject the framing that we need it and fully agree with you about the negative effects. The long term effects of people "being given" jobs or school placement I think are more negative than positive and you are seeing that. The Irish, Italian, Jews, Chinese, and Koreans were all able to get to parity or better without affirmative action.

Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by noofen on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @04:50PM (#26335148)
> The Irish, Italian, Jews, Chinese, and Koreans were all able to get to parity or better without affirmative action.

This of course assumes that genetic (racial) differences in intellectual (and physical, for that matter) ability do not exist. This has never been proven to be the case [1], and never will.

We all know dog breeds have different intellectual and physical characteristics. Why are humans supposedly immune from this? Because it is a morbid reality that throws a wrench in the "all men are created equal" liberal lie.

This is not me advocating for gross eugenics or even discrimination. I just want to point out something frequently missing from these conversations.

"The worst form of inequality is to try to make unequal things equal." – Aristotle

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ

Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by skannamalai on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:16PM (#26335501)
Biologist with a background in genetics here- there is no compelling evidence for statistically valid differences in measured intelligence on a racial genotypic basis. Most attempts to sort races by intelligence (e.g. The Bell Curve) end up being poorly designed junk science.

Dr. Adam Rutherford is a great pop science presence for debunking, or at the very least, addressing the claims that intelligence tracks with race on a genetic basis if you're truly interested in this topic.

https://youtu.be/3F0YSyeQavU

Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by noofen on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @06:37PM (#26336443)
I agree with some of Taleb's critiques of IQ as a whole, and am quite interested in this topic. I will check out Dr. Rutherford's talk, thanks!
Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by newbie789 on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @06:23PM (#26336290)
It’s fascinating that you’ve so casually compared people to dogs.

Out of curiosity, of the groups of people that are impacted by affirmative action, which groups remind you of which breeds and why? For example, are women border collies? Or some other breed?

Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by noofen on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @06:34PM (#26336414)
Every day people have innocuous conversations such as "Ohhh, look at how cute that Border Collie is. I heard they're herding dogs and are very intelligent. I wish my Lab was half as intelligent as those Border Collies..."

When it comes to humans, it's just "purely socioeconomic factors" causing intelligence differences between races. The alternative is simply too morbid for our "nice" liberal society to accept.

I would argue denial of reality always causes more suffering than it purportedly "prevents."

Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by newbie789 on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @08:27PM (#26337425)
I understand that it might be difficult for nice liberal society to accept that dogs and people differ identically.

Considering that it appears as though you’ve accepted this concept as being true, can you please give me an example of an actual category of people that you feel is analogous to a category of dog? I don’t see how that would be difficult.

I understand your desire to make the point about things that may be hard for squares to swallow, but what exactly is this truth that you’re privy to? So far this point seems a bit like gesticulating without actually committing enough to make a statement of substance.

Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by skannamalai on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @05:17PM (#26335528)
BTW your own linked source, the Wikipedia article states clearly:

"The current scientific consensus is that there is no evidence for a genetic component behind IQ differences between racial groups."

Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by noofen on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @06:34PM (#26336423)
Yes, it's the biggest lie of the 21st century. Every scientist that does not agree with the "consensus" on the genetic-IQ link is almost always fired and ostracized from academia.

Even James Watson saw the same fate.

Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by ceph_ on Thursday March 04, 2021 @06:20AM (#26341073)
You believe there's a conspiracy against racists and promotion of racist ideas in science?
Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by panic on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @10:25AM (#26329519)
Yeah, I don't know what the answer is. It feels like any attempt to design a solution ends up having to work around racism or, as you said in another comment, having to "take the devil's (racist's) advocate position". And sometimes the racism even takes the form of someone playing devil's advocate, in an honest attempt to make sure the solution is "realistic", but actually advancing the racists' position for them. The goal ultimately has to be to get to a place where we never have to think about what the racists will do because they don't have power any more.
Re:AI ethics research conference suspends Google sponsorship by noofen on Wednesday March 03, 2021 @04:52PM (#26335171)
"I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character."

Oh, how far we have strayed.