Re:The US IPO cartel
by ghshephard on Wednesday June 08, 2011 @06:08AM
(#2632590)
In California, when you (A) Hire a realtor and (B) List your home, the seller determines both the sellers and buyers commission, and it's 100% negotiated (well, the sellers commission is. You just chose the buyers commission). Not sure where the myth of "6%" (not 7%) commission came from. I paid my realtor a 2% base fee + a 5% kicker on anything above a base amount for selling my condo, and a flat 2% to the buyers agent. Took her six weeks of open houses to sell my place, and overseeing the renovations, and she cleared a net 2.3% on the final price. (this was in 2006) - She was with a top tier realty agency as well, Caldwell.
Can't comment on other locations, might be different.
Re:The US IPO cartel
by tedunangst on Wednesday June 08, 2011 @11:08AM
(#2633396)
I've heard from several homesellers who were quite convinced either you couldn't negotiate down (or that you wouldn't want to), unless you were doing repeat business. There may be some more flexibility now because I think people are getting increasingly frustrated and looking to alternatives.
Oh, found an article from 2004, so things have been changing for a little longer than I thought, but I think it makes clear that 6% was not always a myth. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB109364276315603265.html
That also makes little sense; in the UK, estate agent fees / commission is somewhere between 1% and 3.5%, and they are negotiable.
Where do you find realtor fees to be 7%? In California, 6% is usually the most anybody pays, and thats negotiable.
Re:The US IPO cartel
by tedunangst on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:49PM
(#2631846)
You're right, it's 6%. Tt was just so convenient to have them be the same, it overrode my memory.
Percentage-based fees are rarely appropriate, imo; for those paying the fee, naturally. It's a phenomenon that we simple seem to take for granted. I believe that any system where fees are based on percentages is ripe for disruption. I include this particular case, credit card transaction fees for merchants, ebay, estate agent/realtor fees and so on.
Of course, where the market is closed/protected, then the only way to change it is to lobby politically. And good luck with that in the banking domain.
But I question if there is always a cartel whenever service fees lump together. If you collected the percentage of dinner checks paid as a tip, you'd see an enormous concentration right around 15-18%. Are all the waiters colluding? Even the ones where tip is not included?