> The argument order is still the same (src,dest, the correct order in my opinion)
OTOH dest, src matches every assignment ever, and is much more regular when extending to multi-parameter mnemonics (e.g. madd).
Re:How to Read Assembly Language
by colejohnson66 on Tuesday March 02, 2021 @09:34AM
(#26315704)
I’m going to ignore the characters such as % and $, and also the parameter order (sortove)
There’s also the fact that the Intel and AMD x86 manuals list them as
MNEMONIC dst, src1
GAS does this: MNEMONIC src1, dst
Which is fine, but what about 3 and 4 operand instructions? I always have to look that up. 8087 FPU instructions also (in GAS), due to a historical quirk, are in “Intel” form: MNEMONIC dst, src
Then there’s that whole indirect syntax of: segment:displacement(base,index,scale)
Whereas “Intel” syntax is much clearer: segment:[base + index*scale + displacement]
This leads to weird things like: [ebx*2+10] ; I can see what that’s doing
10(,%ebx,2) ; I need to remember what the order is and convert it in my head
I’m not trying to convince anyone here. If you like “AT&T” syntax, that’s fine with me. I just prefer “Intel” syntax because of these reasons.
So while the changes might not be as huge, it's definitely not just Intel.