News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by jerf on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @11:06AM (#2629400)
"Every single criticism of Bitcoin I've seen is based on the assumption that it will fail because it's not a fiat-based currency."

Then you're being willfully blind. Even in the very article at hand, it points out that there is a standard economic criticism applicable to deflating currencies that BitCoin may be vulnerable to. That has nothing to do with its fiat-ness, it is simply a characteristic of deflating currencies of any kind.

You may not agree, or you may think BitCoin has some clever solution to the problem, but there are numerous criticisms that are much more sophisticated than "it's not a fiat currency".

(Another one being the "it has no backing", which is not a claim that only a government can back a currency, it is observing that it has no backing at all. I'd be perfectly fine with a credible non-governmental third party that provided a credible backing (and both "credibles" are important there, I did not just repeat myself), but there isn't one, and again, that has nothing to do with it "not being fiat".)

In fact I think most criticisms of BitCoin are not that it simply isn't a fiat currency.

(On a general note, if you are planning on being a BitCoin activist, it is important to learn and understand the arguments your opponents are making. You can not counter an argument you do not deeply understand. Sticking fingers in ears and chanting "la la la!" is psychologically appealing, but you're sacrificing all ability to persuade when you do it. There are good arguments against BitCoin. For that matter you can't engineer solutions to problems you don't deeply understand.)

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by vrotaru on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:37PM (#2630095)
Even in the very article at hand, it points out that there is a standard economic criticism applicable to deflating currencies that BitCoin may be vulnerable to.

Yes, the armchair deflationary spiral theory. With the exception of labor theory of value, I do not know of any other economic theory whose premises are a) so thoroughly laughable b) lacking any kind empirical evidence.

In an attempt to reduce the noise/signal ratio (usually high) in such debates... Yes, I know the usual arguments in favor of Deflation Scare and I devoted a fair amount of time thinking and debating these matters. Done my homework, so to speak.

But feel free to surprise me, with an argument I missed.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by jerf on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @02:55PM (#2630391)
That's your persuasive counterargument? "That theory sucks"? I don't deny the standard case is controversial (which is also, BTW, not the same as "lacking in any evidence"; there's plenty of evidence, it's just that what it means is still debated), when discussing deflation spirals of a relatively small size, but when you're talking about a currency that will deflate by orders of magnitude, and that necessarily must do so if it going to be any sort of successful, I think you need more than "Ha ha ha! I laugh in the face of your argument!" I do not know of a real world parallel of such a thing, and when it comes to systems this complicated the presumption by any sane systems engineer is that your new proposal won't work. I for one am not going to take it as axiomatic that BitCoin is inevitably going to work and the burden of proof is on those who think it won't work (another psychologically tempting position). Quite the opposite.

You claim to have done your homework... have you considered actually sharing it with us? Or are derisive italics all you really have?

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by vrotaru on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @04:18PM (#2630688)
That's your persuasive counterargument? "That theory sucks"?

Thank you, you've put it more succinctly than I did. As for "plenty of debated evidence" it just means no evidence. Evidence should be evident, I'd say.

when you're talking about a currency that will deflate by orders of magnitude

How about you (or TAOTFA) have a look at a) Bitcoin Monitor b) The "Buying" section on bitcoin forums c) this:

*You may be right, but I have some anecdotal evidence to the contrary. Since the $10+ spike in bitcoin prices we've sold considerably more shirts in our store.

http://forum.bitcoin.org/index.php?topic=13087.msg181094#msg...