News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by knieveltech on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:53AM (#2629339)
The number 1 reason why bitcoin will fail: Silk Road (et al) have handed legislators all the ammunition they need to go after it with a vengeance. All of what's coming next has happened before. Think e-gold, act II.

Simply put there are no incentives (and massive disincentives, both perceived and real) for any government to tolerate financial transactions in anything other than fiat currency. The more popular the service becomes the more frenetic legislative and enforcement activity will become to stamp it out.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-gold

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by paisible on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:01PM (#2629925)
Isn't that what the distributed system aims to solve in the first place ? If they can't shut bittorrent down, how can they shut bitcoins ? They can crack down on the e-currency exchangers, but only those that operate within their jurisdiction. Would like to know if anyone has concrete examples of how they would go about doing this.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by knieveltech on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:23PM (#2630020)
Sure, and distributed file sharing aimed to protect file sharers from the kind of crap the RIAA has been dishing out since it's inception.

I would expect governments first to limit the viability of the currency, possibly through legislation (fines, jail time) aimed at businesses operating within their borders. Get caught dealing in bitcoins, go to jail.

If that doesn't dampen enthusiam I would expect the next phase to target ISP's. Mandated traffic monitoring and/or blocking, etc. Distributed networks don't mean shit when the connectivity medium isn't available.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by pnathan on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @11:55AM (#2629624)
I support bitcoin and think it is a Good Way Forward, but I agree categorically with your critique. It is sufficiently disruptive that I expect the major players in governments will legislate it out of existence.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by hcho on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @12:48PM (#2629870)
They might legislate against it, but will they be able to enforce the legislation?
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by sorbus on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:20PM (#2630008)
Throw a non-negotiable 1-year imprisonment into whatever penalty they enact for using bitcoin. Then imprison the thousand most prolific users (business that accept it, people who publicly exchange it, etc.), and continue doing sweeps of anyone who admits to using bitcoin for the next few years. Suddenly, the only people who are willing to use bitcoin are those who are already using it for illegal things.

Keep in mind that they don't need to kill the entire system, they just need to make it too risky for the average person to even consider using. That is sufficient to make it fail.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by pnathan on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:39PM (#2630108)
Exactly. Add to that a propaganda stream, "Only Evil du jour will use Bitcoin. Are you Evil? No! Then you won't use Bitcoin either!"
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by aupajo on Wednesday June 08, 2011 @12:17AM (#2632003)
I heard Hitler uses Bitcoins.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by tabsa on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @03:14PM (#2630460)
I'm sorry but this is silly. What you are suggesting has been already tried in prohibition of alcohol, in war on drugs and now in a more civilized way in a "war on car downloaders".

The main outcome was that black markets flourished. If people want what Bitcoin provides, they will get it in one way or another.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by sorbus on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @03:51PM (#2630588)
> If people want what Bitcoin provides.

That's the key point. There is a huge demand for alcohol, for drugs, and for cheap/free content. In the first two cases, this means that there is real profit to be had in selling it, and the illegality means that prices can be hugely inflated due to risk. For free content - "car downloaders" is a really nice way to describe it - I haven't yet figured out the economic motives, but it seems to be a mixture of selling ads (for the people running the sites), sharing/giving back to the community (especially on private, invitation-only trackers), and just because of how easy it is.

Is it possible to make money or karma off of bitcoins in a similar way? Well, you can sell them. If you have bitcoins, you can make a profit of them that way - you can sell them for above value, or charge for the service as well as the coins. You can also buy them, hoping that the price increases, which ends up as selling them.

So, answer this: if bitcoins were made illegal, what monetary incentive would there be to use them? Their price certainly wouldn't go up - it would plummet as all the legitimate traders tried to get out.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by knieveltech on Wednesday June 08, 2011 @03:11PM (#2634584)
Hate to burst your bubble but comparing demand for alcohol during prohibition and demand for quasi-anonymous online value transfers is what most folks would call an obvious strawman. What percentage of the population of the US do you think has even heard of bitcoin, much less understand the underlying concepts?

Everyone I know that's even aware of (much less involved with) bitcoin atm falls under the following demographic: young technophiles. A small minority of these are buying up more GPU's and giggling about the "free money" they're making.

It's a mistake to confuse speculation on the part of some early adopters with actual broad public demand. Expect popular demand for bitcoin about the time that credit cards stop working on Amazon.com.

In the mean time the IRS has every reason to stomp on this before it gets any bigger and all the excuses legislators need have been laid out on a silver platter.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by puredemo on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @11:45AM (#2629568)
It'll still thrive in all the countries that don't legislate against it, and in the black markets of those which do.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by knieveltech on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @12:42PM (#2629851)
That's one possible outcome. Another being bitcoin traffic provokes government-mandated deep packet inspection/filtering or other further intrusions into online privacy.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by puredemo on Thursday June 09, 2011 @07:11AM (#2636687)
It sounds like that might spark the first real "cyber wars." I'm not sure most governments would survive it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7g0pi4J8auQ