News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by furyg3 on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @09:43AM (#2629062)
Not defending BitCoin (I won't be buying any soon), but I think the author doesn't realized that BitCoins are divisible down to eight decimal places.

It's difficult for me to imagine a currency which is so divisible being "hoarded to death".

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by michael_dorfman on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @09:52AM (#2629092)
The divisibility has no bearing on the hoarding.

The hoarding comes from the expectation of increased value over time, not the number of decimal places. If you have something that you think is going to steadily appreciate in value over time, why sell it now?

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by tibbe on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:03AM (#2629132)
There are natural limitations to how much people will save:

* When you're dead all your savings are worthless (to you), so your likely to spend most of them before then.

* Some consumption cannot be postponed: you need food, a roof over your head, transportation, etc.

* Time has value. For example, if you wait another 6 months the same amount of money (bitcoin or not) will buy you a better computer. This is likely to hold true in the foreseeable future. Still people do but computers (and phones, etc).

* There's opportunity cost: even if your savings increase in value over time, investing them in something could increase them even more.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by po on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:20AM (#2629199)
When you're dead all your savings are worthless (to you), so your likely to spend most of them before then.

If that were true, why would there be so much debate around the estate tax? Warren Buffet is a rarity. Most people want to pass money down through generations rather than spend it as they near the end of their lives. Taxes on inheritance encourages spending and charitable giving.

Some consumption cannot be postponed: you need food, a roof over your head, transportation, etc.

Given. Probably not enough to avoid depression though.

Time has value. For example, if you wait another 6 months the same amount of money (bitcoin or not) will buy you a better computer. This is likely to hold true in the foreseeable future. Still people do but computers (and phones, etc)

You seem to be arguing for deflation. Given that I can wait and get a better computer there's even less incentive to spend it today. I remember a study that showed for a computationally intense problem (many years) you could finish sooner by waiting part of the time and buying a faster computer. That's even less incentive to move money around.

There's opportunity cost: even if your savings increase in value over time, investing them in something could increase them even more.

Not if the economy is depressed.

In sum, the natural limitations you site - even if they worked - are not enough to avoid depression. A small bit of inflation is a good thing. Think of a dollar/bitcoin/whatever as a unit of work and inflation as 'urgency'. :-)

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by reedlaw on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:34AM (#2629264)
You seem to suggest in all these cases that spending is inherently good. Estate tax = incentive to give away. Inflation = incentive to buy now. I understand this is one of the core concepts of Keynesian economics. But there exists an alternative school of thought that posits that inflation causes volatile business cycles and central banks are inefficient at allocating resources. Success of a bitcoin-based economy would seem to support the correctness of this Austrian school of economics. We shall have to wait and see.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by po on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @11:12AM (#2629428)
True, I do believe that money flowing from one person to the next (i.e. spending) encourages progress and opportunity. I think those are (on balance) good things. I think it's good to have some convection in the pool.

I don't want a central bank to 'allocate resources' but I don't mind when Wall St. closes due to panic selling or the market closes when someone blows up a skyscraper while everyone figures out wtf that means. I think sports are better with referees. Kill-the-man-with-the-ball is only fun for the biggest guy. Football is a better game.

What we have right now is great but I also don't think Bitcoin is going in the right direction. If you think bitcoin will be less volatile than the overall economy now think about how much easier it would be to corner a market in BTC than USD. Think about how easy it will be to buy off a politician. I don't think democracy can survive under bitcoin.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by 3am on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @11:48AM (#2629590)
That doesn't have the slightest thing to do with Keynesian economics.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by mikey_p on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:52PM (#2630168)
The concept of hoarding in the original article and in this thread is fundamentally identical to a liquidity trap.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by rmc on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @11:59AM (#2629644)
your likely to spend most of them before then.

This does not happen that much in human behaviour. Just look at all the people who inherit wealth. If what you said was the most common approach, they would be rare.

even if your savings increase in value over time, investing them in something could increase them even more.

Depends. Over the last year bitcoin has seen a ~20,000% return rate. If bitcoin gets uberpopular (i.e. each coin is worth ~ US$2m) within 20 years, then BitCoin would have a return rate of ~ 85% per year consistantly for the next 20 years. There is practically nothing else with that close an return rate, so the only financially sound course is to hoard your BitCoins, not invest them

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Fail As A Currency by rubashov on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @12:34PM (#2629804)
The article overlooks that fractional reserve banking is totally feasible with bitcoin. Bitcoins will not inevitably sit on people's hard drives doing nothing, hoarded. Saved bitcoins will likely wind up as reserves in some bank, just as with dollars, from whence they are loaned out.