Re:The Wikipedia war over Paul Revere
by philwelch on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:10PM
(#2626939)
"This is similar to the Orwellian incident where Palin made a true and factual comment about the fact that you can see Russia from an island in Alaska, Tina Fey made fun of it by changing the words to say that you could see Alaska from her house or office, then people started promoting the Tina Fey comedy routine as if it was reality."
Hm, I really saw that as an analog of Bush's "you forgot Poland" incident--it's not so much that the statement itself is wrong, so much as the fact that it's a hilarious non-sequitur to the question at hand. Being able to see Russia from an island in Alaska does not magically grant the governor of Alaska with foreign policy experience, just as Poland joining the US, UK, and Australia in the initial invasion of Iraq doesn't turn a handful of countries into a strong multilateral force.
Hm, I really saw that as an analog of Bush's "you forgot Poland" incident--it's not so much that the statement itself is wrong, so much as the fact that it's a hilarious non-sequitur to the question at hand. Being able to see Russia from an island in Alaska does not magically grant the governor of Alaska with foreign policy experience, just as Poland joining the US, UK, and Australia in the initial invasion of Iraq doesn't turn a handful of countries into a strong multilateral force.