Bingo. Central bankers have wanted direct access to consumers for decades. Policy makers resisted. Cryptocurrencies are a political tool for disabling that opposition.
It's a policy tool, not a technology. They could set up a cbdc with minim effort technologically. The problem would be getting the congressional approval to use it the way they want to use it.
Wish I could upvote this post more times.
The amount being invested does not translate into any bearing on reality.
That is not a matter of centralised accounts, but policy. Central banks could just as well have mailed a check, but they are simply not allowed to.
> The reason being that Central Banks have unleashed interventions that 20 years ago were unfathomable. And yet, deflation is everywhere and money velocity barely has a pulse
Because they are tasked with monetary stability, and they used the only interventions they were allowed to. And that was challenged at court. It would have been the governments job to drive the economy up, because quite evidently, it was not a lack of credit-lines which staled it. But up until recently there was no political will to do so.
Sorry, I don't see how that could be the case: Either you need congressional approval, or you don't.
And how is the technical implementation of money transfer going to have an impact on that?
I think this structurally has less resistance than writing physical checks. What's the point of designing and implementing that system if they aren't going to be allowed to use it.
Nothing that follows in this paragraph depends on the pre-condition of having a digital currency wallet.
> I think this structurally has less resistance than writing physical checks.
That may be, but I find it hard to judge. I am skeptical if the decision to shell out a couple of billions depends on physical checks or not. You could also argue the reverse, a check works better for advertisement for the governing party. People get something physical that is worth something.
> What's the point of designing and implementing that system if they aren't going to be allowed to use it.
There are other use-cases. Direct depositing stimulative is one possibility, but from my point-of-view hardly a game-changer. Direct withdrawal/devaluation on the other hand...
The main motivation I see though is more to compete with PayPal/Visa/MasterCard/Apple Pay/Google Pay..., and all the classic banks. The motivation is not to lose relevance, and if designed correctly, I can opt out of monetising my buyers history & private information.
I don't think it's the main motive, the central bank could send money directly on my bank account if they felt like it.
As I said previously :
> Digital currencies allow for full tracking of every transactions and are a privacy nightmare.
> They allow applying negative interest rate on everybody and they would facilitate neverending hyperinflation (no need to print new bills at great expense).
> Hence they can't coexist with cash so say goodbye to cash.
> I don't like where we're going.
Cash is a specific form of money. There is no such thing as digital cash (or maybe, all digital money is "digital cash"). Digital money on the other hand is all around us. I can't remember the last time I paid for something with cash. But I spend digital money every day. I get paid with digital money each month, I sit on the couch and spend digital money on Amazon, and I routinely tap my iPhone to use Apple Pay to spend digital money in shops. It's just moving bits around a database.
Reading between the lines of what Central Bankers mean is that they want national accounts (i.e. wallets) and using crypto/blockchain/whatever as justification. The reason being that Central Banks have unleashed interventions that 20 years ago were unfathomable. And yet, deflation is everywhere and money velocity barely has a pulse. The transmission mechanisms for monetary policy are broken...well, CB'ers broke them. So now they are looking elsewhere. Direct payments are the final frontier, and it's a lot easier to do by giving everyone an account with the CB (i.e. "wallet") and just print money there.
TL;DR - money is already digital, what central banks really want is centralized accounts that they can helicopter money into