Re:The U.S. Air Force just admitted the F-35 stealth fighter...
by rbanffy on Thursday February 25, 2021 @07:21AM
(#26262080)
> It does one thing well
The importance of this engineering principle cannot be overstated. It applies to everything - from home appliances to spacecraft to software.
Re:The U.S. Air Force just admitted the F-35 stealth fighter...
by pas on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:58PM
(#26268864)
Interestingly it does a bunch of things well, fast and takes amazing pictures, goes very high, etc.
But most importantly those are synergistic, they form a coherent whole, we even say one thing, because it does so well at these things simultaneously that we now consider it almost inseparable.
The SR-71 was designed to do one thing. Go fast and take pictures. It didn't carry bombs. They eventually tried to put a drone on it and it didn't work and was abandoned.
You don't even have to look back as far as the SR-71 though, the F-22 was a reasonably successful program - bumpy, expensive, but it produced what is the world's preeminent air-superiority fighter. It is not a bomb truck, it does not land on carriers. It does one thing well.
Others are not wrong about the fact that the F-35's merit to Congress was as a jobs program, either. This is in fact what a lot of military spending really is. We build tanks only to drive them into the desert and store them, all to keep those production lines running and keep people employed. They could be building trains or something else equally well.
The underlying problem there is that the US political system has become byzantine and cumbersome. When "played" adversarially with all "players" using the maximum extent of their political powers, it takes supermajority control of all three branches of government to govern. This has promoted a byzantine system on top of that to try and come up with mechanisms to fix a broken, unfair, and non-representative process. Massive over-spending on military as opposed to other types of government-sponsored research, production, etc are only one side effect of that.