News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Half of the top 50 Wikipedia contributors are bots by scott_s on Monday June 06, 2011 @01:50PM (#2625610)
When I find errors in Wikipedia articles, I add a section to the Talk page explaining my reasoning, citing sources if I can. Then more "established" people can make the edit.

As far as sourcing errors goes, think about it from the perspective of a generalist. For any given "correction," I think it's fair to assume that the change is more likely to be wrong than correct. The generalist who curates many pages is probably not qualified to determine either way, so the safest thing to do is revert back to the old version. Hence, sourcing corrections can give them confidence that the change is more likely to be correct than the original.

Yes, this is difficult. But I think that's it's inherently difficult. That is, providing a vast source of knowledge covering many topics digestible by non-experts is inherently a difficult endeavor.

There are no comments on this comment yet.