News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by nhangen on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:05AM (#2624524)
The war on piracy is like the war on drugs. Giant waste of time and resources, will never end, and no gets out without losing an arm.
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by rick888 on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:14AM (#2624553)
The problem is that piracy destabilizes the price of whatever is being pirated. Digital goods are only worth what people are willing to pay and if everyone knows they can go to thepiratebay and get it ford free, it will be $0.

So even though companies know they will never win the piracy fight, it sends a message that it's not okay to download it for free (as opposed to doing nothing).

Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by eftpotrm on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:45AM (#2624640)
No.

I don't deny there is a demographic that will always obtain for free what it can but it's a lot below 100%. Witness the documented effect of services like NetFlix on piracy levels or the warnings in software such as PDFCreator or Paint.Net that if you paid money you were conned. For whatever reason, some people will pay for the freely available.

Not to mention that, very often, material via sources such as TPB is of lower quality - inexpertly cut off at the start or finish, periodic glitches, whatever. Plus it's hardly got high availability and consistent cataloguing. People will pay for a reliable, quality service.

Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by rmc on Monday June 06, 2011 @01:06PM (#2625433)
In my experience TPB and pirated content is as good quality as DVDs. They are mostly better since there are no FBI warnings that I can't skip over, crappy trailers, and hard to navigate menu systems, as well as stupid region encoding. If you pirate it, you get a better quality product.
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by rick888 on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:59AM (#2624699)
yes.

"For whatever reason, some people will pay for the freely available."

If piracy wasn't stopped and it was advertised everywhere that in all the search engines that you could get commercial software for free, these numbers would be very close to 100%.

"Not to mention that, very often, material via sources such as TPB is of lower quality - inexpertly cut off at the start or finish, periodic glitches, whatever. Plus it's hardly got high availability and consistent cataloguing. People will pay for a reliable, quality service."

TPB has a search box. software is a perfect copy, music is usually near perfect, and many times the movies (not always), are ripped right from the studio or DVD.

Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by cookiecaper on Monday June 06, 2011 @11:57AM (#2625131)
I disagree strongly. The Pirate Bay is infested with malware, fake torrents, media monitoring companies, and lots of other undesirable stuff. It is difficult to navigate and use.

Here's the way that record companies should make money: $20/mo for access to that company's entire catalog, unlimited download, well-organized, high-quality rips, vetted torrents (i.e., uploaded by the company itself, malware free), etc. If you've ever used one of the big private music trackers they make an excellent prototype for a for-pay service that would allow the rights holders to rake in even more money than they currently make. They were eventually able to figure it out with VHS, I don't know why it takes them so long with the internet.

Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by rick888 on Monday June 06, 2011 @12:15PM (#2625212)
"I disagree strongly. The Pirate Bay is infested with malware, fake torrents, media monitoring companies, and lots of other undesirable stuff. It is difficult to navigate and use."

There is a rating system. If there is a virus, someone will complain. How is it difficult to use? looking for Photoshop? put it in the search box and click "search".

"Here's the way that record companies should make money: $20/mo for access to that company's entire catalog, unlimited download, well-organized, high-quality rips, vetted torrents (i.e., uploaded by the company itself, malware free), etc. If you've ever used one of the big private music trackers they make an excellent prototype for a for-pay service that would allow the rights holders to rake in even more money than they currently make. They were eventually able to figure it out with VHS, I don't know why it takes them so long with the internet."

The record companies already negotiated with terrorists and lost, why would they believe that this time will be any different. You can get songs for 99 cents, Netflix tons of movies, preview music through Grooveshark, Last.fm, and Pandora. Yet, it's still not "enough". Piracy is worse than never and there are a new set of excuses as to why you have a need (and a right) to downloading someone else's hard work for free.

The beginning of the entitlement generation.

Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by guard-of-terra on Monday June 06, 2011 @04:39PM (#2626499)
"Piracy is worse than never" Is it? Something to back this claim up?
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by rick888 on Monday June 06, 2011 @06:08PM (#2626929)
haha,

There is a pirate party in Sweden and sites like thepiratebay get millions of visitors per day.

Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by rick888 on Monday June 06, 2011 @07:00PM (#2627130)
Love the down voting too. Proves to me once again about the political nature of HN and why a pure democracy doesn't work.
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by WorkingDead on Monday June 06, 2011 @10:27AM (#2624810)
The price isn't being destabilized. The reproduction cost of digital goods IS zero. The initial creation cost of that first version is quite significant however. Copyright laws are meant to protect that initial investment for a period of time so that huge creation cost plus a reasonable profit can be made. This limited monopoly is the incentive to create. In return for that government granted monopoly period, the copyrighted work then goes into the public domain where market forces and competition determine the new price of the good or service. This is the public's incentive to grant a temporary monopoly. Piracy is running rampant because the laws have been manipulated and skewed in favor of the content generators so their work get all the protections but no longer ever fall into the public domain. The collective public thus no longer have incentive to follow copyright laws and have quite a bit of incentive to violate and disregard them as totally and as quickly as possible.
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by rick888 on Monday June 06, 2011 @12:24PM (#2625260)
"The price isn't being destabilized. The reproduction cost of digital goods IS zero."

It was never about the reproduction, it's about the original and the "value" to the user. If they know they can get it for free, they will download it for free. How is this not destabilizing?

Currency is just ink and paper and pretty much costs nothing to reproduce, yet it has a value.

"Piracy is running rampant because the laws have been manipulated and skewed in favor of the content generators so their work get all the protections but no longer ever fall into the public domain."

Right, because people that are downloading the latest Lady Ga Ga album are doing so because of these laws. Why can't people admit that they are selfish and just don't want to spend their own money because they know they can get it for free?

"The collective public thus no longer have incentive to follow copyright laws and have quite a bit of incentive to violate and disregard them as totally and as quickly as possible."

Piracy is running rampant because:

1) The Internet is now mainstream and it's very easy to tell mass amounts of people how to download something for free. 2) The risk involved with being caught for pirated materials is almost non-existent.

It's funny because when the discussion is about open source and the GNU license, opinions quickly change. Using software against the spirit of the license is "theft" and shouldn't be allowed. Even though it does nothing to harm the original content creator (the original open source work is still there and open, you just don't get the changes).

Months ago when there were discussions about the Thesis wordpress theme, there was nearly a witch hunt on HN. This is why it's difficult to take any of these discussions seriously. It's all about politics and has nothing to do with freedom or rights.

Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by WorkingDead on Monday June 06, 2011 @01:48PM (#2625603)
Both currency and 'intellectual property' only have value because they are backed by the government. Currency is very hard to reproduce without a substantial investment and has a lot less anonymity when being used. IP, on the other hand, can be redistributed in mass with a 5 year old computer you pull out of a dumpster almost completely anonymously. Piracy just isn't going to go away without public sympathy to the cause. Its like why everyone throws a fit when you violate an OSS license but actively encourages downloading a track from the latest pop artist. The public receives value from the one and has it extracted from them by the other. People are smart and can tell when they are getting screwed even if they cant sufficiently articulate how its being done.

In my opinion the only feasible way to fix the system is to bring copyright duration back to a reasonable time period, like maybe 10 years or so, with a way to extend that duration for high value properties. One way would be to declare value on that particular property, paying property tax on that value, and limiting the liability of infringement damages to that declared value.

I'm not saying that piracy would go away totally at that point, but certainly more legitimate business models would emerge and even illegitimate ones would make the transition to reduce risk. Cost of enforcement would also go down as the volume of infringements decreased and those resources could be concentrated and directed along with a greater public support and sympathy. If the public can actually see that they get value out of protecting copyrights they will. If not they wont. I have zero incentive to protect the latest pop artists music if it will never go out of copyright in my life time, but if see that I can do whatever I want with it in 10 years, then yeah, I'd stick up for them and so would a lot of others.

The big label/studio/publisher companies dug themselves into this mess with a money grab and pretty much lost all sympathy from everyone that they cant buy off. Their only way out of this is to either be more open with their content or go back to fair laws. Other wise, the rest of us will go on without them. It also comes down to culture. Like it or not, music, movies, books, games, software, or whatever are our culture. You just cant reasonably expect people to not not have access to their culture forever. Its fair to have to pay for the latest and greatest, but as it is now, there is pretty much zero free access to anything since 1927 and that system just doesn't work. Now with technology, people just circumvent the unfair system like they should.

Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by demallien on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:39AM (#2624612)
Except that that's not true - I would cite iTunes as a counter-example - easy (and reasonably-priced) trumps free.
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by teamonkey on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:45AM (#2624638)
The pay-for download market has been in decline for the last few years.
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by Fargren on Monday June 06, 2011 @11:58AM (#2625135)
What's your source on that?
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by rick888 on Monday June 06, 2011 @10:01AM (#2624701)
yet, piracy is still rampant. I just wish the pirates would admit that it has nothing to do with "freedom" and everything to do with being selfish.
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by tomp on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @07:30AM (#2628677)
Of course they are. Just like the content industry is. Everybody is just being selfish.

You are still assuming that all piracy (= unauthorized copying = disrespect of copyright) is wrong. While it is illegal, it doesn't automatically mean that it is also illegitimate. What if someone is too poor to spend money on legal music? Nobody loses anything by him pirating music, and he gains something (entertainment), so overall, the outcome is positive.

Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by danssig on Monday June 06, 2011 @10:03AM (#2624705)
If pirating were at least as convenient as buying, then sure. But pirating is a lot of trouble. You have to have custom software that serves no other purpose than this. You may have to hunt for codecs. You have to make sure you're getting the right thing. If it's a foreign film (90% of what I view) you have to dig around for subtitles which are often very poorly written and/or don't sync with the film properly.

Pirating is a pain and I think most people would pay something to avoid having to do it. The question is just how much and how convenient it is to do so.

Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by eru on Monday June 06, 2011 @12:42PM (#2625344)
You can also learn the foreign language in question.
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by danssig on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @04:38AM (#2628360)
I was arguing that I will pay for convenience and your solution is that I learn Mandarin?
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by eru on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:43PM (#2630128)
You can pay for convenience in some situations, and put in more effort in others.
Re:Piracy: are we being conned? by rmc on Monday June 06, 2011 @12:58PM (#2625401)
DVDs and music cds are still being sold for >0, and it's more than 10 years since Napster. These facts are inconsistent with your theory, so like a good scientist, your theory (that piracy will makes prices = 0) has been disproved