Re:WWDC 2011 Prelude
by masklinn on Monday June 06, 2011 @02:09AM
(#2623853)
> He's trolling for pageviews/loyalists and I hate that
Meanwhile you're trolling for karma and you love that?
> I keep reading his articles expecting [...] objectivity
Oh come on, you're not writing that seriously now are you?
> Really? Not plugging your phone into USB and then fucking about with iTunes is "dare I say game-changing". What decade are we in? Oh wait, maybe this quote was missing some critical bit of context... If so, fill me in. If not, FTFA.
It's game changing not because it's novel, Gruber is in fact well aware that Android or WebOS have had OTA sync of everything for a long time (he's mentioned it several times in the past), but because it plugs one of the biggest holes in the iOS platforms, especially w.r.t. the iPad: the systematic reliance on computer tethering for almost all operations. That is a major iOS drawback right now, and a major advantage of competing platform. If Apple can plug this hole, the value proposition of iOS (again, especially on iPad which feels much like a computer and on which the over-reliance on computer tethering really is uncomfortable) skyrockets.
> Oh wait. Netflix. (To which someone says, "but they don't have everything"; to which I say, "they will".)
Netflix does not let you buy movies. That seems to be what Gruber has issue with here: if they pull a movie from their catalog, it's gone. The point of buy would be to stay in control of the media: if the studio decides to pull the movie from the catalog, you still have it. If you want to download it to whatever device for offline viewing, you still have it.
> If I wait longer, will this sentence become not-dumb?
I don't know, do you think waiting will teach you the fine arts of understanding written words?
Meanwhile you're trolling for karma and you love that?
> I keep reading his articles expecting [...] objectivity
Oh come on, you're not writing that seriously now are you?
> Really? Not plugging your phone into USB and then fucking about with iTunes is "dare I say game-changing". What decade are we in? Oh wait, maybe this quote was missing some critical bit of context... If so, fill me in. If not, FTFA.
It's game changing not because it's novel, Gruber is in fact well aware that Android or WebOS have had OTA sync of everything for a long time (he's mentioned it several times in the past), but because it plugs one of the biggest holes in the iOS platforms, especially w.r.t. the iPad: the systematic reliance on computer tethering for almost all operations. That is a major iOS drawback right now, and a major advantage of competing platform. If Apple can plug this hole, the value proposition of iOS (again, especially on iPad which feels much like a computer and on which the over-reliance on computer tethering really is uncomfortable) skyrockets.
> Oh wait. Netflix. (To which someone says, "but they don't have everything"; to which I say, "they will".)
Netflix does not let you buy movies. That seems to be what Gruber has issue with here: if they pull a movie from their catalog, it's gone. The point of buy would be to stay in control of the media: if the studio decides to pull the movie from the catalog, you still have it. If you want to download it to whatever device for offline viewing, you still have it.
> If I wait longer, will this sentence become not-dumb?
I don't know, do you think waiting will teach you the fine arts of understanding written words?