News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some Thoughts on Cancer from a Hacker by Mz on Sunday June 05, 2011 @07:08PM (#2623073)
This is basically the plot for the movie "I am Legend", starring Will Smith. In that movie, yeah, things go terribly wrong with this approach. (EDIT: And I mention the movie to say that as a thought experiment this has been done before and drew the same conclusion: This has potential to go very, very wrong.)
Re:Some Thoughts on Cancer from a Hacker by rvkennedy on Sunday June 05, 2011 @07:45PM (#2623149)
It's a general law in fiction, going back to Frankenstein, that any development that challenges the status quo will prove harmful. Mary Shelley didn't call it "The Modern Prometheus" for nothing - the implication is that to challenge our limitations offends the gods, or God, or Nature. It's a great way to make people feel OK about mortality or failure. And a guaranteed trope - when a TV episode or movie starts with a new development in science with great promise you know 100% by the closing credits that the scientist will have been punished and the status quo ante restored.

I would guess that when the first crazy experimentalist tried putting seeds in the ground instead of foraging for fruit, there was a cave painting about how the Spirits would punish the whole tribe for its arrogance.

Re:Some Thoughts on Cancer from a Hacker by Mz on Sunday June 05, 2011 @07:49PM (#2623160)
Well, I'm kind of familiar with that firsthand since my hobbies include getting myself well when doctors claim it cannot be done. So I get called a liar, charlatan, and snake-oil salesman...blah blah blah... by folks who think it just cannot be done. Still, the idea of intentionally introducing a virus to cure cancer doesn't sit well with me. :-)
Re:Some Thoughts on Cancer from a Hacker by krakensden on Sunday June 05, 2011 @11:05PM (#2623536)
My mother was working for a (now extinct) biotech company that was developing a cancer 'vaccine' using a retrovirus to do targeted removal of cancer cells. One of the big problems they ran into was that the patient's immune system had a tendency to kill off all of their cancer-killer viruses.

So for a while there, they were seriously working on making a virus that would be completely invisible to your immune system- and this was maybe eight years ago. I'm sure there are dozens of little biotech companies in the bay area alone trying to do the same thing now.