Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by anoonmoose on Monday February 22, 2021 @12:23PM
(#26227186)
If one football team got beat 8-0, and another football team got beat 9-1, should we really be spending time arguing about which team is better when they're both pretty obviously not very good?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by mod on Monday February 22, 2021 @01:46PM
(#26228577)
No, we shouldn't argue about which one is better.
If we're coaching the team that lost 0-8, we shouldn't try to run the playbook of the team that lost 1-9 in the next game. Especially when that playbook cripples our players in other ways--perhaps academically (to expand your analogy).
Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by SpicyLemonZest on Monday February 22, 2021 @12:46PM
(#26227563)
It's not about teams, it's about attempting to evaluate the counterfactual. If the difference between the US and Australia is primarily due to lockdowns, you would expect to see areas with more lockdown do better than areas with less. Much better, to a degree that drowns out any noise, since the overall difference is so vast. And that really doesn't seem to be what we observe.
Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by anoonmoose on Monday February 22, 2021 @12:54PM
(#26227687)
You're acting like there were parts of the US in 100% lockdown vs 0% lockdown, when the difference is a lot more like 20% (max) vs 10%, and it's a lot harder to suss out any difference in result when the difference in practice is that small.
Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by SpicyLemonZest on Monday February 22, 2021 @01:06PM
(#26227898)
If lockdown explains most of the variance between Australia's 1k deaths and America's 500k deaths, then the difference between 10% and 20% lockdown should still be very visible.
Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by zuminator on Monday February 22, 2021 @02:12PM
(#26229018)
That doesn't follow. Imagine the effective spread ("Re") of a disease averages 1.5. Certain external factors, such as climate, population density, access to medicine, diet, etc. can cause a 0.2 plus or minus variance in Re. So, 1.3-1.7 range. Each 10% of lockdown will cause a 10% reduction in that amount. So if Florida does a 10% lockdown, its Re will be somewhere in the 1.3-1.7 range reduced by 10% or 1.17-1.53. If California does a 20% lockdown, its Re will be in the 1.04-1.36 range. California, if "unlucky" can still have a worse Re (1.36) than Florida if "lucky" (1.17). Meanwhile Australia at a say 70% lockdown would see numbers in the 0.39-0.51 range, well below sustained transmission levels even if "unlucky."
Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by SpicyLemonZest on Monday February 22, 2021 @02:26PM
(#26229242)
Makes sense. Thanks for doing out the math, that's pretty convincing to me.
Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by mcguire on Monday February 22, 2021 @01:22PM
(#26228139)
Few relationships in the real world are linear. That is just an assumption that makes the math easier.
Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by SpicyLemonZest on Monday February 22, 2021 @01:33PM
(#26228348)
Sure, but there's a point where the hypothesis just becomes unfalsifiable. Is there any evidence that would convince you lockdown policy isn't the primary factor here?
Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by anoonmoose on Monday February 22, 2021 @01:32PM
(#26228343)
That's a big "if" at the beginning of your sentence.
Re:Opinion: We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April
by SpicyLemonZest on Monday February 22, 2021 @01:34PM
(#26228375)
I'm not sure what you mean. That was the "if" that started this comment thread - an assertion that the US would be back to normal already if only it had done what Australia did.