Re:Rebooting the cosmos?
by jerf on Sunday June 05, 2011 @02:14PM
(#2622518)
This debate always reminds me of an older debate, about how the universe must have a maximum speed, and how the universe can not have a maximum speed, as outlined in [1]. The resolution was ultimately that yes, both were actually true, and the failure of understanding was somewhere else entirely: Galilean transforms are the wrong way to add two velocities, you need Lorentz transforms, and both of Zeno's arguments are thus satisfied.
Similarly, while you don't get it from this source as he has made his decision, there are some reasons why everyone has gone to discrete models. But I suspect the ultimate resolution will have both elements, which the essay does mention at the end, and that contra what the author says, there won't be an "ultimate" to either of them; I bet the universe can not be discrete and it can not be continuous, and the truth is some weird combo of the two in which ultimately the question is simply sidestepped, not resolved, much like the resolution to Zeno's paradoxes.
Similarly, while you don't get it from this source as he has made his decision, there are some reasons why everyone has gone to discrete models. But I suspect the ultimate resolution will have both elements, which the essay does mention at the end, and that contra what the author says, there won't be an "ultimate" to either of them; I bet the universe can not be discrete and it can not be continuous, and the truth is some weird combo of the two in which ultimately the question is simply sidestepped, not resolved, much like the resolution to Zeno's paradoxes.
[1]: http://www.mathpages.com/rr/s3-07/3-07.htm