Re:Rebooting the cosmos?
by andrewflnr on Sunday June 05, 2011 @07:21PM
(#2623097)
I think his point regarding whether discrete or continuous descriptions are more fundamental is that you can (always?) describe a discrete system continuously, but you can't always reduce a continuous system to a discrete description. Continuity is more general, and since we seem to see it a lot, it's probably the way the universe actually works.
At least that's how I feel about it. But hey, I'm not a particle physicist either.
I don't think the universe is a computer either, but I don't think this guy understands what that would mean anyway.
From the article: "I just find it obvious that pretty much by definition, discrete objects are always less fundamental and less complete than the continuous ones. A discrete description of some object or phenomenon is always an approximation."
Now the whole thrust of the "computer-universe-ism" people's argument, if I read them correctly, is that the universe is really a discrete structure, in which case a discrete model of said structure would not be ANY kind of approximation. I.e. to what are the integers (a discrete structure) a (supposedly poor) approximation? What about the two-element set {0,1} or (say) groups? (The group theory bit is a trick for the author.)
We'd better leave these questions to be answered by empirical data---or if we need philosophers to chime in, better ones than this.