News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube blocked chess channel after mistaken detection of... by Aerroon on Sunday February 21, 2021 @09:04PM (#26219877)
Why do we need laws around this? We need to hold the people accountable that put this into production and/or produced it. People should be able to build bad AI, but if that causes poor real world outcomes, then the people that okay'd its use need to take responsibility.

"An AI erroneously banned the channel," shouldn't get any more leeway than "A support staff member banned the channel."

Re:YouTube blocked chess channel after mistaken detection of... by amirkdv on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:16PM (#26220453)
> Why do we need laws around this? We need to hold the people accountable [...] [T]he people that okay'd its use need to take responsibility.

Genuinely asking: what do you think profitable companies would do to their ML engineers over a product issue like this if there was no law under which they would be sued?

I think accountability without an enforcement mechanism is just a wishful suggestion.

Re:YouTube blocked chess channel after mistaken detection of... by Aerroon on Monday February 22, 2021 @03:27PM (#26230099)
>what do you think profitable companies would do to their ML engineers over a product issue like this if there was no law under which they would be sued?

Nothing. Maybe a reprimand at best, because the consequences of this are fairly minor. If a store erroneously bans you and them unbans you and says that there was a mixup with their policy, then what do you think should be the consequences to the store? If it's effectively a monopoly then I can see there being problems, but if it's just a random store then that doesn't really matter.

Re:YouTube blocked chess channel after mistaken detection of... by CydeWeys on Sunday February 21, 2021 @09:36PM (#26220139)
> "An AI erroneously banned the channel," shouldn't get any more leeway than "A support staff member banned the channel.

What would curtail the leeway then? Other than losing public trust in the product for this happening repeatedly anyway?

Re:YouTube blocked chess channel after mistaken detection of... by texasbigdata on Sunday February 21, 2021 @09:14PM (#26219968)
Because the inner bias that humans have that might lead to similar exclusion is implicitly hidden and somehow excused and the machines are held to a higher standard, for some reason.
Re:YouTube blocked chess channel after mistaken detection of... by notriddle on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:01PM (#26220351)
Apple uses 100% human labor for their app reviews. They get about as much accountability as Google does.

Personally, I think the AI is a total red herring.