News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Activists who embrace nuclear power by acdha on Sunday February 21, 2021 @08:42PM (#26219698)
This is especially worth considering in light of what recently happened in Texas. Say we get a really good setup: teams of nuclear and process engineers doing the best work of their careers, money is no object when it comes to safety, etc. and build infrastructure safe against once-in-10ky events and everything is executed perfectly.

All of that costs money, and sooner or later some MBA / politician is going to ask why we’re spending so much on something which hasn’t come anywhere near a major event – surely we’d be just as safe spending 10% less and using the money for something else like rewarding shareholders? Setting up governance structures which can resist that kind of pressure for millennia isn’t something we have much experience with.

Re:Activists who embrace nuclear power by EricE on Monday February 22, 2021 @02:08PM (#26228958)
Actually Texas makes a great argument for more, smaller and distributed reactors.

Micro molten salt reactors make a lot of sense if looked at rationally. Can burn what we currently call "waste" too.

Re:Activists who embrace nuclear power by acdha on Monday February 22, 2021 @02:23PM (#26229188)
That’s a different question. The real underlying issue in Texas was that every producer had an incentive to be cheaper but not to winterize, because they’d immediately see wins from being cheaper on the marketplace and could gamble on going years without a winter failure — by which time the person who made that call might not even be working there any more.

When talking on this kind of scale about a system level failures, the social issues are going to dominate unless it’s something like a fire-and-forget space probe. If you want to see nuclear succeed, the first thing I’d be thinking about is how to ensure that someone doesn’t cut safety to boost their profit margin, accounting for possible future regulatory capture and austerity budgets. Since nuclear is never even going to be within one order of magnitude as distributed as wind/solar, I’d especially think about what would prevent some unscrupulous CEO from pocketing the difference comfortable in the knowledge that their family doesn’t live anywhere nearby.