News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project Xanadu by zozbot234 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @06:55PM (#26218619)
> This was done a decade and change ago with Movable Type's trackbacks feature and that was, as you guessed, a massive spam vector.

This is not an insurmountable problem. You can choose to accept trackbacks only from sites that can point to endorsement by some mutually trusted 3rd party. This is ultimately how the Fediverse works - bad actors will get booted from the most popular networks and find themselves unable to 'push' content to the network. And modern federated-web standards include the "trackback" case, e.g. via WebMention.

Re:Project Xanadu by DaiPlusPlus on Sunday February 21, 2021 @08:16PM (#26219425)
> You can choose to accept trackbacks only from sites that can point to endorsement by some mutually trusted 3rd party. This is ultimately how the Fediverse works - bad actors will get booted from the most popular networks and find themselves unable to 'push' content to the network.

I suppose this would have worked in the 2005-ish era when MovableType, Pingbacks/Linkbacks, and Web 2.0 was all the rage, but in today's internet culture and its very partisan politics (...of a distinctly American flavour...) permeating everywhere, the concept of "endorsement", even in a technical sense, can be framed as a political gesture, even if the basis of an endorsement can be defended on purely technical grounds. We saw this happening with the "Twitter Verified" badges controversy (as the identity-verification of an account is a purely technical and factual thing, but because Twitter chose to use the imagery-of-endorsement to indicate verified accounts it led to... well, that's another discussion). My point being that even if a pingback/linkback/trackback system can accurately filter-out (commercial) spam, maintainers of those websites would likely still want to curate pingbacks anyway - which means still having to actively moderate/audit that, and who wants to spend their time doing that?