News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by sneak on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:56PM (#26216541)
How nice, you'll still be able to receive messages, but not reply.

I hope this puts a real taste of the censorship these platforms arbitrarily wield into the mouths of millions of people.

Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by lucb1e on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:01PM (#26216585)
That's not censorship, that's generous. If you don't agree with the Google terms of service, it's not as if you can make use of their services. Facebook apparently allows people to still have WhatsApp, run the software, connect to the servers, and receive messages. Presumably to make other people talk to those users, making them want to reply, and then sell their soul after all, rather than haunting those users off the platform altogether. It's clever and insidious.
Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by sneak on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:42PM (#26216968)
Whether or not is it generous doesn't change the fact that is is censorship.
Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by lucb1e on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:25PM (#26217380)
To censor: "to examine in order to suppress (see suppress sense 2) or delete anything considered objectionable" (Merriam Webster).

That's not what this is. Nobody is reading messages or selectively withholding them. They're denying access to certain parts of the service for people that don't want to agree to the service's contract (I said, mostly jokingly, that this is "generous" because most other services just stop working altogether if you don't agree; I obviously don't think Facebook is the benevolent party here, as the rest of my previous comment made clear).

Whether that contract Facebook offers is reasonable and just, or whether perhaps we can consider WhatsApp public infrastructure due to its ubiquity and importance in certain countries, is a separate discussion.

The new contract may not be fair to require because people often don't really have a choice to move away, but for it to be censorship there has to be more than "we can't provide you a service because you didn't agree to our contract under which we provide it". If I don't agree that Deutsche Post sells my metadata to third parties, it's not suddenly censorship if Deutsche Post refuses to then deliver my letters. They're not censoring my letters, they're telling me to go and find another delivery service or deliver my own damn letters.

Which, to get back to the point, you can do on https://matrix.org.

Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by sneak on Sunday February 21, 2021 @05:51PM (#26218166)
> Nobody is reading messages or selectively withholding them

Facebook is selectively withholding messages sent by users who haven’t agreed that Facebook should get to arbitrarily and unilaterally change contract terms at any time.

Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by lucb1e on Sunday February 21, 2021 @06:07PM (#26218286)
Somehow I feel like we are speaking different languages.
Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:58PM (#26216559)
don't forget - as long you are being harmed by a private corporation and not a government - it's A-ok!
Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by HenryBemis on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:09PM (#26216658)
You cannot escape an evil government.

But if you don't like the services of a private corporation, just drop it. Nobody is forcing anyone to use WhatsApp. Pleople decide to do so. We are all free, and I believe we can all affort a (very) few euros/dollars/pounds and buy Threema. Or using Signal for free.

But if your government decides to bump VAT on food at 60%, you cannot escape that. Only leave the country.

Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by Mediterraneo10 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:05PM (#26217174)
Whatsapp has basically replaced the public telephone network in some countries. It is the only way that many businesses can be contacted; they won’t respond to normal phone calls or SMS, and they don’t maintain a website or Facebook page. Even some government offices will insist on being contacted via Whatsapp. So, even if you bought Threema or used Signal, you would still be quite isolated from the society around you.

Once a product development by a private company becomes essentially necessary public infrastructure, obviously there are concerns.

Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by mixedCase on Monday February 22, 2021 @01:15AM (#26221401)
Then that's a problem that needs to be solved. And the only way to solve it is to have people who don't use WhatsApp and refuse to. If the business doesn't take email, SMS, phone calls, Signal or Matrix they can go without my business, and I am already reaching out to those that may be at risk. And it doesn't happen here, but if a government office were to refuse contact other than whatsapp then I would sue. Why on earth should Facebook be given the power to dictate and process how I communicate to gov offices? It's insane and requires immediate response by citizens.
Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by corobo on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:50PM (#26217046)
Nobody's forcing you to use whatsapp other than a little global pandemic forcing all interactions online aye

Now's not the time to cut yourself off from your support network and Facebook knows it. Gross.

Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by MikeUt on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:38PM (#26216935)
If these private corporations decide to censor some message, an individual "just dropping" them won't help them spread the message one bit.
Re:WhatsApp Reveals What Happens to Users Who Don't Agree to... by grawprog on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:35PM (#26216905)
Well how else could they tease you into eventually accepting the terms? You get that little dopamine hit from a notification, but can't deal with it until you accept their terms.

It's fairly insidious.