Oh wow! Was it an interesting theorem that got proved this way? Did it get proved in another, less controversial manner as well? Could you provide a pointer to it?
If you assume P, derive a contradiction, then conclude not P, that is a direct proof of negation not a proof by contradiction.
In Kevin's example where you have two programs, one which depends on the Riemann hypothesis being true and the other which depends on it being false, is that you can't just execute the programs -- they might have undefined behavior since they depend on the truth of some statement during their executions, and there's no general algorithm to decide whether undefined behavior is happening. They depend on undecided facts, so you can't put them together into a single program that decides the result. (Maybe a slogan is "truth can be contingent, but data cannot be.")
In Lean syntax, this is an example type signature of something that takes two programs (h and h') that respectively take in the truth/proof of a proposition or its negation, along with a proof that there is at most one element of α, and produces that element. I don't think there's a way to write this definition in Lean without marking the definition noncomputable:
def extract {p : Prop} {α : Type*}
(h : p → α) (h' : ¬p → α)
(unique : ∀ (x y : α), x = y) : α := sorry
(the sorry indicates a missing definition).That’s where opinions will differ. That’s only true if you accept the law of the excluded middle.
Mainstream math does, but most constructive math does not.
Yes, Kripke semantics makes sense of constructive logic. Topos theory, too. But I really think of all of these embedded in classical logic, and assuming that the law of excluded middle doesn't hold for general reasoning just doesn't make any kind of sense to me.
p.s. could you let me know your e-mail so I can keep for future reference, as I'm also working on a hobby project for automated theorem solving.
Here is the reason why it's obvious for mathematicians. If you're trying to prove a theorem (e.g. the theorem that class numbers of imaginary quadratic fields tend to infinity), and then someone comes up with a proof which assumes that a certain generalisation of the Riemann hypothesis is true, and then someone else comes up with a proof which assumes that the exact same generalisation is false, then we mathematicians say "great, the theorem is now proved". This actually happened.
However if your boss asks you to write some code which does a calculation, and the next day you show up in their office with two USB sticks and say "this code is guaranteed to produce the correct answer if the Riemann hypothesis is true, and this other code is guaranteed to produce the correct answer if the Riemann hypothesis is false" then you are going to lose your job, because all you did was prove that the code exists, which is less helpful than it could be.
For me one of the biggest problems with the area of formalisation of mathematics is that for decades it has been dominated by computer scientists, whose view of what is important and beautiful in mathematics does not really coincide with that of the working mathematician. This is what I am fighting to change.