News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please do not put IP addresses into DNS MX records by chrisseaton on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:31PM (#26215812)
> Why not follow the standards?

Because they can't send email when they follow the standard?

What are you trying to achieve? Following a standard for the sake of it, or are you actually trying to send email?

And what's the point or use of a standard that people aren't following? What's the point of following such a standard?

Re:Please do not put IP addresses into DNS MX records by tinus_hn on Monday February 22, 2021 @07:55AM (#26223937)
No, it’s the other way around. You can’t receive mail from standards-compliant servers if you don’t follow the standard.

What the point is of the standard requiring you to use a name instead of an IP address is a reasonable question but not the same question as whether you should follow the standards.

Note this is a standard made by people who knew what they were doing and it has stood for 35 years. There’s always room for improvement but it would be a bit silly to think you can just handwave it away with arguments you can come up with in a few seconds. There is bound to be a catch.

In this case the catch of course is that there are more address types than IPv4 addresses, so the system requires you to specify what kind of address you are talking about. The mechanism for that is the A record, which only holds IPv4 addresses.