News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by intricatedetail on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:18AM (#26214582)
Bill is included in the income tax. Funnily enough it does not apply to people living off shares, they truly pay £0 or close.
Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by blacktulip on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:25AM (#26214661)
Do you mean stock dividends? They are taxed - and not lightly: https://www.gov.uk/tax-on-dividends
Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by vidarh on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:44PM (#26215416)
Well, capital gains is taxed much lower. Also combined with the ISA limits (20k put into ISA's each year - do it every year and your returns start adding up), you can get quite significant returns without paying tax at all. The UK tax system looks a lot more progressive on the surface than it is once you earn enough to take advantage of the various tax breaks.

That said, few people will pay nothing - what they won't be paying if they live off share return (be it dividends or capital gains) is national insurance. I'm assuming that's what the person you replied to meant.

However that means nothing in terms of NHS funding any more, as NI just goes into the general treasury fund in practice.

It's become part of a convenient fiction about UK tax rates, given that most people are unaware of the way NI is structured. In effect the "20%" marginal tax band is roughly 32% marginal when you factor in NI, and the "40%" marginal tax band is really 42%, and the 45% band is effectively 47%.

The 20/40/45 looks a lot less progressive when it's actually about 32/42/47 (even less so when you factor in the many tax breaks those of us on the higher or additional rate can afford to take advantage of that lower earners can't)

Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by geden on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:21AM (#26214614)
Dividends are mildly taxed now.
Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by vidarh on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:35PM (#26215353)
Capital gains are. Dividends ends up effectively taxed similarly to income when you factor in that dividends are taxed after corporation tax. This is very intentional in that it closed much of the loophole of paying yourself via a limited company paying dividends. Still a bit cheaper but not much.
Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by uncledave on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:10PM (#26215145)
This. I wish people would stop saying the NHS is free because it's not.

It's equal for everyone regardless of your income and that's awesome as far as I'm concerned. Some others, not so much, particularly those who think that they shouldn't pay for someone else's treatment.

Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by ljf on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:56PM (#26217116)
The NHS is free at the point of delivery. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Health_Service_(Eng...

It is not free like a free buffet.

But if you have a need, and a doctor/nurse agrees, then you get the treatment at no cost/free.

Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by chrisseaton on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:16PM (#26215217)
> It's equal for everyone regardless of your income

Are you familiar with the term 'postcode lottery'?

And what impacts which postcodes you can live in? Your income.

Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by uncledave on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:21PM (#26215255)
Yes. That's why there is the NHS Choices Framework which allows you to choose both GP and outpatients. My GP is 40 miles away. My daughter is treated for her condition at Guys even though we're 20 miles away and there is a different local hospital.

The postcode lottery doesn't exist unless you're dragged into an A&E.

Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by matthewmacleod on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:36PM (#26215354)
Honestly that whole system is nice idea on the surface that rapidly becomes a nightmare - in my view doing little except encouraging health inequality.

One of the big problems is that "choice" is much more expensive for some people than others; this means that while I might be able to take a day off an visit a hospital a couple of hours away, it's much harder for someone who does't have access to transport, healthcare, funds or whatever else is required. So that system ends up offering choice only to people who can afford it, and you end up shuffling the poor people off to the less effective local healthcare facilities and your postcode lottery is back.

Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by aksss on Sunday February 21, 2021 @05:44PM (#26218092)
Are there countries/cities you would point to that have gotten this right? (i.e. proximity of everyone to better quality care regardless of neighborhood?). I mean, some of it is just a function of where doctors prefer to live when they are successful enough to have a say in the matter. Those with a say, like all of us, probably prefer nicer neighborhoods/offices.
Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by chrisseaton on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:23PM (#26215266)
> My GP is 40 miles away...

Great! Everyone can afford the time and expense of travelling far away to a better GP... oh no wait that also depends on income.

Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by uncledave on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:34PM (#26215339)
Erm no it doesn't

You think I actually go and see the GP? No they call me instead and talk any problems through. I haven't been to a GP for about 10 years and have had a few appointments and referrals.

As for the transport costs, for referred appointments that's covered under HTCS if you can't afford to travel.

Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by chrisseaton on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:38PM (#26215369)
> I haven't been to a GP for about 10 years and have had a few appointments and referrals.

Good for you? What about people who do need to regularly go and see their GP?

> As for the transport costs, for referred appointments that's covered under HTCS if you can't afford to travel.

What about those GP visits some people less fortunate than yourself need?

And HTCS is for extremely low-income people. It doesn't cover normal working class people's extra costs.

People less fortunate than yourself struggle to get equality in the NHS. Sometimes they don't even have the knowledge and confidence that you do to use the systems you're talking about.

Fundamentally they shouldn't be required, rather than fortunate people saying 'I'm alright Jack'.

Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by vidarh on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:45PM (#26215426)
While I absolutely agree with you in principle, it's still worthwhile for people to know that a growing number of GPs offer permanent (as in not just during covid) video consultations, and that they can choose treatment, and GPs, further away.

Though I think we agree it'd be much better if they didn't need to.

Re:Saving children’s lives with world-first ‘dead’ heart tra... by DanBC on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @02:49PM (#26241983)
GP registration in England is a little bit complex.

If you live within the GP catchment area, and their list is open, they must register you and there are very limited reasons why they can decline that registration. GPs must offer certain services to this group of patients, including home visits if needed and an out of hours service (although that's often contracted out).

If you live outside the catchment area they have a choice. They can either:

register you and provide full service, or

register you but not provide out of hours or home visits, or

not register you.

Full details are in the Primary Medical Care Policy and Guidance Manual (PGM): https://www.england.nhs.uk/publication/primary-medical-care-...