Why not both? I’m paying for my card by mining when I’m not gaming. I checked with a watt meter and I’m using 270-300 watts mining total (cpu, gpu, etc). It also heats my room so it’s more efficient than running a heater or using a space heater (1500 watts).
Good comparison though it misses some externalities.
Gamers also use monitors(~40W) for many hours a day, and run the whole machine with 1 card while many miners minimize all other costs but the GPUs. Also gamers typically damage their cards a bit faster and change them for newer ones faster on average (miners keep mining with very old cards still).
First some variables:
Mining energy usage: Gaming energy usage: So even with someone who I'd consider a high volume gamer (8 hours per day) uses less than half the energy of running a miner for a day. You'd have to game for over 18 hours per day to use more energy than a miner. Of course both the gamer and the miner end up using a chunk of metal and plastic that will end up in a landfill so that bit counts the same.Note: From what general figures I've seen online the energy works out roughly the same for the rest of the recent RTX series cards (some such as the 3060Ti work out a few % more favourable for mining as they are more energy efficient overall)