News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by aminozuur on Sunday February 21, 2021 @06:31AM (#26212687)
What about the US military's FB page? Didn't they cause thousands of innocent deaths in Iraq? I'm sure some Americans can somehow justify it, but I doubt the grieving Iraqi's will accept it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mukaradeeb_wedding_party_massa...

Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by ArkanExplorer on Sunday February 21, 2021 @08:49AM (#26213404)
I think you are misunderstand the point of Facebook's actions.

The purpose is not to harm or pressure the Burmese military authorities -

Its to virtue signal to left-leaning activists in the USA and other Western Countries.

Technology companies have dug themselves into a hole of censorship and deplatforming, and they have no choice but to keep digging.

Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by tshaddox on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:13PM (#26217253)
I am always impressed at how effectively Facebook has convinced nearly everyone on both sides of the US partisan divide that Facebook is using censorship to attempt to crush their own side.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by newacct583 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:41AM (#26214243)
Only "left-leaning" people oppose the Myanmar coup?
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by wutbrodo on Sunday February 21, 2021 @12:15PM (#26215202)
The details of the coup aren't understood or cared about that deeply by American discourse. But the idea that it's trivial and salutary to identify and ban "bad" or "dangerous" speech is decisively left-coded right now, in exactly the way similar impulses were right-coded during periods of rightwing political dominance (immediately post-9/11, parts of the Cold War, etc)
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by barbacoa on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:06PM (#26216145)
All these recent events involving censorship and left aligned tech companies eerily reminds me a passage the Unabomber wrote in his manifesto back in the 1990s.

" Some leftists may seem to oppose technology, but they will oppose it only so long as they are outsiders and the technological system is controlled by non-leftists. If leftism ever becomes dominant in society, so that the technological system becomes a tool in the hands of leftists, they will enthusiastically use it and promote its growth. In doing this they will be repeating a pattern that leftism has shown again and again in the past. When the Bolsheviks in Russia were outsiders, they vigorously opposed censorship and the secret police, they advocated self-determination for ethnic minorities, and so forth; but as soon as they came into power themselves, they imposed a tighter censorship and created a more ruthless secret police than any that had existed under the tsars, and they oppressed ethnic minorities at least as much as the tsars had done. In the United States, a couple of decades ago when leftists were a minority in our universities, leftist professors were vigorous proponents of academic freedom, but today, in those of our universities where leftists have become dominant, they have shown themselves ready to take away from everyone else's academic freedom. (This is "political correctness.") The same will happen with leftists and technology: They will use it to oppress everyone else if they ever get it under their own control. "

Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by wutbrodo on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:28PM (#26216327)
Exactly. I don't share the Unabomber's directional disdain for leftists, but most people are simply too dim to understand the concept that liberalism/illiberalism exists on an axis independent of leftism/rightism. If you're planning to burn down liberal norms for short-term partisan gains, you better understand the long view, but that's simply beyond the capacity of the majority of people.

To be clear, there are leftists and rightists that explicitly own the rejection of liberal values (Communists/tankies, racial essentialists like the "woke" and neo-Nazis, neoreactionaries). But the majority of these dynamics are driven by useful idiots who can't even grasp what's happening.

Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by covidthrow on Sunday February 21, 2021 @05:39PM (#26218045)
Not entirely sure why you're being downvoted—maybe some are reading your list of groups, seeing their own, and saying, "well they were right up until that part," and got offended—but you are correct that illiberalism exists on all sides of the political spectrum.

And of course when it does, the now-illiberal faction rationalizes it with some manner of, "liberalism, except when..."

The problem with liberalism is that—while it is the most sane mode of structural organization—it is extremely brittle in the face of illiberalism.

Liberalism—and its ancestors/influences—never ate itself, unlike illiberalism. But it does always fall to barbarism. It's like having an argument with an insane person: you may be right, but you'll never win that fight.

That is a seriously concerning weakness, because when liberalism is threatened, the default modes of self preservation are either: roll over and get beaten (as a matter of principal) or reject some (or all) liberalism in order to fight back. In either case, liberalism goes away.

I'm not sure that anyone has ever come up with a reasonable defense. (And maybe there is none.) Humanity seems to prefer pendula. The grass is always greener...

Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by wutbrodo on Monday February 22, 2021 @04:27AM (#26222450)
> Not entirely sure why you're being downvoted

I've definitely learned not to be fazed by downvotes on political topics, especially in the current political environment. Like I said (and like you say, more diplomatically), most people are just too dim to understand not only this dynamic, but the very concept of liberalism.

Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by asxd on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:55AM (#26213126)
The difference is the Myanmar military was killing their own citizens.

A country's military firing live rounds on their own citizens with seemingly no remorse is different than a country's military committing violence in foreign countries.

I'm certainly not condoning either example of military force presented here, but the duty of the military should ultimately be to preserve their citizens. Killing its own citizens and then using social media to lie about it is something I don't think the US military has done.

Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by angio on Sunday February 21, 2021 @08:03AM (#26213162)
Should Facebook then close Police departments pages? They're killing fellow citizens and they're doing that more than any other Police force in the west.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by asxd on Sunday February 21, 2021 @08:11AM (#26213203)
That's a decent point. To my argument though, the duty of the police sometimes does acceptably involve violence against citizens when necessary (although at present they are far too frequently forgetting the "when necessary" part).

Also, police departments are far more localized and I think hold much less clout than a national organization.

Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by mhh__ on Sunday February 21, 2021 @09:02AM (#26213476)
Well, I'm sure at least someone thought about doing that over the summer.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by nix23 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:10AM (#26213983)
Aung San Suu Kyi Defends Myanmar Against Rohingya Genocide Accusations:

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/11/world/asia/aung-san-suu-k...

Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by intricatedetail on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:39AM (#26214830)
The US is inprisoning drug users en masse and forces them to provide labour. That does not directly kill people but prevents them from living it the way they want which is somewhat similar in effect, not to mention all the suicides or related gang violence. Not much different to be honest. Army let politicians get boatloads of cash from prison and pharma industry to keep up the war on citizens. Wake up.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by f6v on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:19AM (#26212952)
An American company will always be a mouthpiece for American propaganda. Not saying whether it’s right or wrong, it’s just the way it is.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by eplanit on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:25AM (#26214651)
Its removal should be actively encouraged amongst the SJWs. FB backing itself, and being backed into, corner after corner helps reveal the hypocrisy more quickly.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by ascold on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:47PM (#26217016)
There is a slight difference though. Myanmar military took over the government. The US military is led by the president of the United States and only the Congress has the power to declare war.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by wil421 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:12AM (#26212906)
Why even bring this up? Whataboutism is a very shallow argument.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by qart on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:18AM (#26212945)
Well, aminozuur is pointing out hypocrisy. Facebook is not applying the same rules to everyone. That is bad. That aside, my own views are similar to sep_field's... with the exception that I would silently prefer Facebook to go away, without explaining why I'd like that.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by vermilingua on Sunday February 21, 2021 @07:14AM (#26212922)
Because it may be shallow, but when discussing the criteria by which they decide what is worth taking down, it is also a very valid argument.
Re:Facebook takes down main page of Myanmar military by vmception on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:22AM (#26214073)
Given that “Whataboutism” really means “hypocrisy in a geopolitical context” I think the entire definition should be updated to reflect it as a very valid observation, instead of the assumption that it is a weak argument because in my experience it usually isnt, even during the height of the cold war the Soviet Union’s observations about the US were accurate.