News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Destroy the Planet: Buy Organic by Turing_Machine on Saturday June 04, 2011 @09:38PM (#2621016)
"How much essential nutrition does it actually give you?"

Well, let's see... a 1 ounce (28 gram) serving of Fritos contains 15 grams of carbohydrate, 10 grams of fat, and 2 grams of protein = 27 grams. All of these are nutrients, so quite a lot, actually. The remaining gram is mostly fiber, which, although not a nutrient per se, is a good thing to eat nonetheless.

I think you're using a non-standard definition of nutrient here.

Re:Destroy the Planet: Buy Organic by pyre on Saturday June 04, 2011 @09:44PM (#2621032)
I was thinking in terms of vitamins and minerals. Also 'protein' is rather nebulous of a term (though I imagine there is some government-approved definition that you have to use when generating those labels). Beans have 'protein,' but would should really have something like beans and rice to have 'complete protein.'
Re:Destroy the Planet: Buy Organic by Turing_Machine on Saturday June 04, 2011 @09:52PM (#2621043)
Those are more along the lines of micronutrients. Your body runs on carbohydrates. In a pinch it can create them from fat or protein, but that's pretty inefficient.

The "complete protein" thing is a myth, at least in the sense that you need to eat (e.g.) beans and rice at the same meal. You do need to get all of the essential amino acids at some point, but they don't have to come in one slug.

Also, the third world diets that you advocate tend to be, to a first approximation, pure carbs. They don't get organic baby vegetables from Whole Foods in January. They get brown rice, or wheat, or, yes, corn meal, for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, every day of their lives with occasional bits of other foods to relieve the monotony.

Re:Destroy the Planet: Buy Organic by pyre on Saturday June 04, 2011 @11:22PM (#2621195)

  > In a pinch it can create them from fat or protein,
  > but that's pretty inefficient.
[citation needed]

See vitamin B-12 and vitamin C, for example. On the other hand, in a pinch your body can convert fat/protein into energy rather than carbs. Though your urine may be smelly from the chemicals it uses.

  > The "complete protein" thing is a myth, at least
  > in the sense that you need to eat (e.g.) beans
  > and rice at the same meal. You do need to get all
  > of the essential amino acids at some point, but
  > they don't have to come in one slug.
I wasn't referring to the idea that they need to be in the same meal. I mostly calling out the fact that 'we' always tend to refer to 'protein,' but it's possible to eat tons of protein and still be missing out on some essential amino acids.

  > Also, the third world diets that you advocate tend
  > to be
Huh? Where did I advocate that? I was using 'rice + beans' as an example. Also, where did I say anything about Whole Foods? You seem to be constructing a bunch of straw men arguments based on the idea that I'm some person that fits into some sort of 'bucket' with other people you disagree with.
Re:Destroy the Planet: Buy Organic by 18pfsmt on Sunday June 05, 2011 @12:20AM (#2621289)
WRT to your request for citation, I can point you toward this[1] (not sure about the protein/ muscle claim) wikipedia post, and quote a portion:

"Ketosis is deliberately induced by use of a ketogenic diet as a medical intervention in cases of non-responsive epilepsy.[6] Other uses of low-carbohydrate diets remain controversial."

What I find interesting is the assumption that everyone operates with an intentional diet. I forget to eat all the time.

EDIT: Maybe I should elaborate to say that I had unintentionally adopted a "ketogenic diet" by accident, and it took me 4 years to figure that out.

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ketosis

Re:Destroy the Planet: Buy Organic by pyre on Sunday June 05, 2011 @02:43PM (#2622573)
Ketosis talks about converting fatty acids to energy (when your body runs out of glucose/glycogen). It says nothing about creating vitamins and minerals out fat+sugar+salt.

If your body could get all the essential nutrients out of nothing but carbs and/or fats, then malnutrition would be a fictitious condition, as would be scurvy (Vitamin C deficiency).