News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006) by Ekaros on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:05PM (#26205724)
I have been wondering about that. Hasn't all of the carbon now in fossil-fuels been in atmosphere at some point? Or has more of it been freed from earth's crust or arrived as meteors since formation of the fossil-fuels? So in the end wouldn't worst case scenario be of around time when they formed?
Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006) by gamegoblin on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:45PM (#26206124)
> So in the end wouldn't worst case scenario be of around time when they formed?

It's worth noting that the Earth's atmosphere would be incompatible with current life at various past levels of atmospheric carbon.

In the past, Earth's atmosphere was almost entirely nitrogen and carbon dioxide[1], but at some point some plucky cyanobacteria learned how to photosynthesize and convert CO2 into O2, hugely changing the contents of the atmosphere [2] and killing a large amount of life that couldn't tolerate the new order.

So if we were to burn all the fossil fuels, it's quite possible that this would cause a climate catastrophe that would kill a large majority of life on earth. But there's a decent chance that the cyanobacteria and friends would survive and, after hundreds of millions of years, restart the evolutionary process.

Note that climate catastrophes take many forms, and the "greenhouse effect" does not even necessarily have to be involved. Take ocean acidification for instance. Atmospheric carbon raises the pH level of the ocean, which can cause cascading ecological collapse.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleoclimatology

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_acidification

Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006) by dTal on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:02PM (#26216111)
>But there's a decent chance that the cyanobacteria and friends would survive and, after hundreds of millions of years, restart the evolutionary process.

I think it's worth noting that on this timescale, we don't have forever:

"In about one billion years, the solar luminosity will be 10% higher than at present. This will cause the atmosphere to become a "moist greenhouse", resulting in a runaway evaporation of the oceans. As a likely consequence, plate tectonics will come to an end, and with them the entire carbon cycle... Four billion years from now, the increase in the Earth's surface temperature will cause a runaway greenhouse effect, heating the surface enough to melt it. By that point, all life on the Earth will be extinct." - from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Future_of_Earth

I submit that this is probably Earth's only chance at a spacefaring civilization, and therefore Earth life's only chance at escaping the planet (and thus surviving the death of the planet). If we flub it and cause a mass extinction without anything to show for it, it is the beginning of the end of Earth's story.

Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006) by sudhirj on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:26PM (#26205947)
This seems to be a weird misconception about climate change, that the earth getting hotter will somehow end all life. That’s very doubtful. All the plants will love the new greenhouse, lots of energy in the atmosphere, rain every day, the whole planet a tropical paradise. It’s the humans and some other species who’ll be heavily inconvenienced. Solving climate change is mostly so we can stay comfortable and not have to deal with more ecological crises and refugees.
Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006) by jbay808 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:45PM (#26206116)
Not necessarily a tropical paradise, if it goes the way of the end-permian mass extinction:

http://burro.case.edu/Academics/USNA229/impactfromthedeep.pd...

Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006) by guenthert on Saturday February 20, 2021 @03:49PM (#26207822)
Only if it get just a little warmer. Photosynthesis is temperature dependent however and its maximum is at a modest 20 degree C, above 40 degree C its efficiency falls rapidly [1]. If it gets much warmer than that, and a run-away greenhouse effect would ensure that, only algae and some bacteria survive a while longer. Once the oceans are boiling, it's hard to imagine any life surviving though.

There doesn't seem consensus on whether Earth could truly reach a runaway greenhouse state or would rather just settle at a higher temperature. In any case, only the ecological (and consequently economic) crises and refugees problem are the ones currently living people will be affected by, but that ought to be enough to take action.

[1] https://sciencing.com/effect-temperature-rate-photosynthesis...

Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006) by dnautics on Saturday February 20, 2021 @04:03PM (#26207946)
I for one am ready to bow down to our giant insect overlords (once the plants get happy they will make more O2 and enable surface diffusion breathers to become giant again)
Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006) by kaybe on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:31PM (#26205996)
Yes, that was the case about 500 million years ago. [0] The climate and planet was very different back then, and it took a long time for the CO2 to go down that much and for life to cause this/adapt to the changes. The life back then wouldn't be very happy if it was transported to today's planet either.

In addition to the greenhouse effect, the location of the continents can also have a major influence on the climate due to the influence on ocean and air currents, the albedo, weathering speed of exposed rock in the tropics and different plant cover at different latitudes etc, thus it is hard draw good comparisons (only modelling is possible, and verification is hard).

To be fair, I do not believe we are capable of life extinction on Earth. We are also not able to make the conditions on this planet worse than it is on any other planet we can reach so far. But we can cause a mass extinction easily and make life for ourselves much much harder. Our situation is so optimized for the current conditions that changes will cause great pain. (Just look at the locations of cities, or how agriculture is run.) If we developed with the climate of 500 million years ago we would be just fine with that. The problem is the fast and large change.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_at...

PS: One more point: CO2 causes some cognitive issues in humans in concentrations above 1000 ppm, which often occurs in meeting rooms and means the windows need to be opened regularly. It's not bad, you just get a little tired and dumber... so you take a break and open the windows. Now imagine the CO2 concentration outside is 5000 ppm (currently at ~415 ppm). We did not evolve for this.

Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006) by gizmondo on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:33PM (#26206019)
There used to be trees in Antarctica just 15 million years ago, you know.
Re:How to Destroy the Earth (2006) by thgaway17 on Saturday February 20, 2021 @12:08PM (#26205756)
Shhh. Some of us are trying to make a living selling green energy.