Re:Things you should do now (2011)
by DavidHilbert on Friday February 19, 2021 @11:01AM
(#26194483)
its not blacklist and whitelist because "black=bad, white=good", black is the abscense of light, hence the light is blocked, white would obviously be the opposite. So its black because you are blocking things, and white because you aren't.
[dead]
“Blacklist” and “whitelist” are confusing terms. Why does “black” mean “no”? There are plenty of reasons to use better terms in new projects other than “they upset people” – though that should be a good enough reason on its own.
If you believe that having "black=bad, white=good" connotations built into our jargon is harmful in some way, then yes, you should strive to use alternate terms.
If you don't think that's harmful, and you're forceful in defending "black=bad, white=good" as being too established and too inconvenient to change, that's when you're likely to get pushback.
Personally I've been trying to use "deny-list" and "allow-list" (with partial success – changing your jargon is hard). They feel a bit clunky, but I suspect that clunkiness will fade with time.