News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by sli on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:22PM (#26184260)
Me. My utilities have always been more reliable than my internet service. Not only do my utilities have far fewer outages (almost none by comparison), they go so far as to inform me in advance before a planned outage, something no ISP has ever bothered to do.

Meanwhile, municipal internet speeds routinely crush what I'm getting from my ISP. No Google Fiber here, and while I do have fiber service, there are no gigabit fiber options here. And we have no say over that. I'd much prefer to be able to vote for gigabit than be angry at a black box that has no reason to make my service better. ISPs don't compete because they don't have to.

Since you made the comparison, I'm quite happy with my city's DMV. The wait hasn't been long in a decade at least, there are 25-30 manned stations, appointments can be made and are kept, and overall it completely bucks the idea that the DMV is absolutely horrible. And this isn't a big city.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by fetus8 on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:17PM (#26184214)
I'm not sure where you live, but where I currently live, scheduling an appointment and visiting the DMV is actually a pretty stress-free and easy task to take care of.

I also happen to live in a city with a municipal ISP that provides 1GB/s fiber service to most of our city. It's the best ISP I've ever had in terms of service and even customer service. Establishing my account was painless, the in-home install was free and scheduled right away. The one time I've had to call their customer service, I got to talk to a live competent person right away too. Never had service like that with Comcast. I imagine I'm not alone with this experience.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by jschwartzi on Thursday February 18, 2021 @04:17PM (#26185706)
We don't even have to go to the Department of Licensing to renew anything here. You can do it all online. The only time you'd need to go anywhere is to apply for a new license or to update your photo or physical characteristics. They even take credit cards.

Government only sucks if you accept it sucking as a foregone conclusion. Hold government accountable and it will stop sucking.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by sudosysgen on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:50PM (#26184551)
We had this in some Canadian provinces. The service was the cheapest in the country and the most liked.

People got very angry when it got privatized. Some people's bills doubled. It wasn't even subsidized.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by mywittyname on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:57PM (#26184638)
>It wasn't even subsidized.

Internet access is insanely high margin. Once the lines are laid, the cost to provide service is next to nothing. The bulk of the costs come from paying off the loans associated with laying the original lines.

There are probably many cities in the country who could provide free 10Mb symmetrical service to every house, then have tiered monthly charges starting at $10 up to $50 for 50Mb to 1Gb services for those who want it, and turn a profit on internet access.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by drdaeman on Thursday February 18, 2021 @03:33PM (#26185101)
> next to nothing

That’s not exactly true, I believe maintenance costs are non-negligible. It’s not like networks are “set up once and forget forever” - over time shit always hits the fan somewhere: lines degrade, network hardware goes haywire (frequently, in subtle ways), so after monitors (or customer calls) indicate an issue, it all requires dispatching people to check and fix. Ot doesn’t help that a significant fraction of the reported issues are in customer’s systems (poor WiFi reception, pets nibbling on the wires, malware, etc), and lots of issues are sporadic and non-persistent (something failing at random for 10 minutes a day is even worse that a complete outage).

I was a software developer working for a (non-US) ISP, and while I wasn’t working in the field I can say that our line engineers were almost always busy.

If it would be easy to set things up, no one would have crappy Internet. The ISP I was working for had a decent competition - IIRC on average our users had about 4-5 alternatives, so unlike some US monopolists we weren’t able to just ignore the issues.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by mywittyname on Thursday February 18, 2021 @09:27PM (#26188821)
True, but a decently-size metro probably only needs an engineer and may 3-4 tech support for every 50k households. In a metro area with 1 million subscribers, that's 20 engineer and maybe 80 tech support, then various administrative staff like payroll, manager, etc (say, another 20 people). Paying salaries of $120k per engineer, $50k per tech support, and $60k per admin, that's $2.4mm + $4mm + $1.2mm = $7.6mm in salaries.

That's $8 per year per subscriber. Yeah, you need to pay for equipment and such as well. But there's plenty left in the budget for that. Even if equipment costs were as much as salaries, the ISP only needs to charge $1.25 per month to turn a profit.

There's a reason Comcast, et al, are fighting so hard to maintain their monopoly: anyone could seriously undercut them on price and still make buckets of cash.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by danaliv on Thursday February 18, 2021 @03:57PM (#26185405)
> our line engineers were almost always busy

I should hope so, otherwise you've hired too many line engineers. :) I think an interesting metric would be how many line engineers you had, and how much they cost.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by duxup on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:16PM (#26184195)
Municipal internet seems to be pretty great considering the other options in most places that it exists.

I wish talking to Comcast was as easy as visiting my local government services ...

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:17PM (#26184202)
Everyone I know who has municipally provided internet has significantly faster and less expensive service than I do. I'll take the DMV over local private monopolies any day.
Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by 1MachineElf on Thursday February 18, 2021 @03:03PM (#26184702)
If you search HN for "municipal ISP", the results are mostly positive, and many I expect have evidence you'd need to make the case for them. I'm not advocating that there should by only municipal ISPs and no commercial ones, just that they should not be made illegal.
Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by vangelis on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:30PM (#26184349)
Why not ask people with municipal internet instead? My parent's county electrical co-op also works well. You get functional local government if you elect people who actually want government to work.
Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by coffeefirst on Thursday February 18, 2021 @03:18PM (#26184900)
Depending on where you live, maybe?

The first time I went to a competent DMV it kind of blew my mind how efficient it can be when the government decides to make it work well.

Our city services are pretty good. They can handle most business and troubleshooting by email, there's a website to request service. Their goal is clearly to get stuff done. It's so much easier than dealing with my ISP or mobile provider.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by cyberlurker on Thursday February 18, 2021 @04:12PM (#26185625)
Exactly, I’ve been to at least 4 DMVs in different states. Some are better than others, but all are better than the service I’ve received from Comcast. In all those same states.
Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by jf on Thursday February 18, 2021 @03:07PM (#26184744)
Respectfully, do you have any evidence to back up your claim that municipal internet service is worse than internet provided by a private company?
Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by prophesi on Thursday February 18, 2021 @03:10PM (#26184796)
Chattanooga's municipal ISP is affordable, profitable, and vastly outperforms the competition. Meanwhile Verizon/Comcast lobbied to stop it from expanding their service outside the county.

If you think local government is inefficient, you should look at the inefficiencies of industries with large barriers to entry and its resulting lack of competition.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by Uehreka on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:56PM (#26184628)
I’d rate the DMV and Comcast as equally bad so if the “DMV ISP” is cheaper than Comcast I’ll take it.
Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by kuyan on Thursday February 18, 2021 @03:41PM (#26185221)
For what it's worth, where I live in California, all of my utilities except for gas are managed by the city government and their prices and service blow the competition out of the water. Didn't have any blackouts last year.

The internet here is subpar, though.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by forgotmysn on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:48PM (#26184543)
remember that you're comparing against companies like AT&T and Comcast. municipal broadband has had almost universal acclaim from users who previously subscribed to those companies
Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by mywittyname on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:42PM (#26184478)
In many states, DMVs are private enterprises that are provided a license by the state to conduct business. I think one way you can tell is if the the DMV handles titles or there's a title office in an annex forcing you to wait in line twice.

A relative of mine runs a few DMVs in my area.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by Analemma_ on Thursday February 18, 2021 @03:01PM (#26184681)
It's always amusing when someone posts "do you want your ISP to be like a utility?!?!" like it's a slam-dunk argument.

Uh, yes, I do? In more than three decades of life, I've only had my power go out a handful of times, and other utilities (gas, sewage, etc.) have literally never gone out- 100% uptime across decades. By contrast, my internet breaks several times a year. And when my power goes out, I know for a fact that a figurative army is going out to fix it as fast as possible. When my Internet goes out, the response from my ISP is along the lines of, "Eh, it might be back soonish. Or it might not. Fuck you."

So, yeah, I would love for my Internet to behave like a utility. It would be a huge upgrade.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by chrismcb on Friday February 19, 2021 @12:08AM (#26189987)
I agree... It basically is a utility. But because they're is "competition" there is no monopoly regulation. Despite the fact that the companies basically have a monopoly. Either treat it like a utility and regulate it. Or treat it like a free market and allow anyone in.
Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by jhayward on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:29PM (#26184335)
My local government operates several utilities, and does it very well and at reasonable prices.

And when there are problems - their board of directors and CEOs are very visible and reachable. Some live in my neighborhood.

Of course, the city government isn't dominated by know-nothing, do-nothing antigovernment types. We try to hire for competence and comittment to mission, not ideology.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by mywittyname on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:45PM (#26184508)
It's a good way to operate.

Cap the profits at something like 10% which is enough to maintain good operation and provide the city with a good reason to continue service. It might be a good idea to prohibit the muni from selling any portion of the service to a third party.

Re:House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal bro... by salawat on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:34PM (#26184395)
I'll sign up. I'd like to be able to petition the government to allocate more funds to improving local infrastructure. Obviously leaving it up to private enterprise is only optimizing for rent extraction with precious little in the way of actual infrastructure improvement.