All the stuff you're talking about is true only on micro scales, assuming that that debt is "owed" to some third party.
In fact this can keep going on forever, really. If the money printers are going Brrr... and no inflation is happening nor buildups of saved wealth, then by definition the economy is increasing in size.
They also lead to brittle economic systems.
In 1900, if everyone was asked to stay home for 3 months, they'd go home for 3 months, and come out not-too-much-worse for the wear. In 2020, when the same happened, crippling mortgage payments, leases, and similar caused a near-total implosion.
Likewise, in 2020, we nearly saw global supply chain break down. In 1800, a global economic crisis couldn't do too much to a town in the midwest growing its own food. In 2020, if, for example, TSMC were to go wonky due to China taking Taiwan, we'd lose over half of our IC manufacturing capacity, including critical components for virtual every other electronic device made.
We're wound really tight. The danger is systemic collapse.
Considering that back then most households spent close to 50% of their income on food and there were basically no social safety nets it's much more likely they would have starved to death by then end of those 3 months...
Of course it has a different impact vs essentially subsistence agriculture, as per your midwest yardstick.
We do have examples of collapses from too much interconnection and trade. A good example of systemic collapse of this sort, from another point in human history, is Late Bronze Age collapse circe 1150BC. There were complex, structured societies which were pretty efficient for the time, due to trade and specialization.
All of the major cultures were wiped out, all at about the same time, when those structures broke down.
There are scientific exchanges, humanitarian aide, artistic exchange, coordination on climate change, and similar, grounded in mutual benefit, but not in mutual interdependence.
These can be big or small silos. Aside from off-grid living, villages, towns, or countries can be independent.
These can also be complete or incomplete. If the tech tree needed for food and transport is local, it's okay if many luxury goods are global.
That's not an argument about debt, though.
It's more efficient to have specialized countries. If Germany and Japan focus on optics, that's more efficient than having an optics industry in each country. Everyone is wealthier.
It's also more brittle; if WWII breaks out again (as a hypothetical), the allies don't have access to optics, and can't repair step-and-repeats. That, in turn, means they can't manufacture ICs. And so on, down the line.
The downside, like the sibling comment mentions, is that complex systems have complex failure modes. Additional links between firms raises the chance that you could get a cascading solvency crisis.
I'd really like to see who holds the debt. Is it widely dispersed - say lots of individual retirees owning government bonds? Or is it a few big financial firms who own all the assets with lots of little debtors? That has big implications for what inflation incentives are.
High debt and low interest rate environment don't guarantee your more stable amd secure society. Only for short term while you keep printing money. While experiencing all kinds of weird societal phenomena, such as markets decoupled from fundamentals, extremely expensive real estate or low birth rates. The low birth rates will actually implode this entire debt and money printing based scheme or some war or similar conflict even sooner.