I used to dread going to any project that was hosted on SourceForge, hate it like going to the dentist for something to get drilled, and while it's a bit better, it's still an awful, uncomfortable experience. When I see a project hosted on SourceForge I only click the link with a heavy sigh.
Why do I "hate" SourceForge? It's because they got complacent, and because they never changed. It was like SourceForge was more important than you and you better not forget it. How many clicks was it to do something as simple as set up a new project? How many forms and emails do you need to fill out or reply to? How annoying was the distribution model, or how ugly was a project page? All these things were important but nobody cared.
That Github was able to turn around block and report so quickly is evidence that they get it, they're listening, and they aren't afraid to hustle and do what's right. Nothing is hard on Github. It is as easy as it should be. I gladly spend money on Github every month. Sourceforge couldn't pay me to use it.
I really hope that the rise of GitHub and similar competitors provokes SourceForge to innovate again.
Exactly. They are, like it or not, the Internet Explorer 6 of the open source hosting world.
SF has a" monopoly" and a "chilling effect" that makes you "angry", because their completely free service was not good enough for someone?
What does Sourceforge owe anyone?
Sourceforge owes nobody anything. And we don't owe it anything either. So don't mind us if we don't help fix SF.
Github is as 'completely free' as sourceforge. Firefox is as 'completely free' as internet explorer. So yes, it does make sense to use 'completely free' and 'not good enough' in the same sentence.
A lazy monopoly has a way of generating extreme hatred due to the impotent rage of the people that use it because they have no other option. SF may have drastically improved in the presence of competition, but it's no surprise that some people are still angry.