Re:Coronavirus human challenge study gets green light in UK
by graeme on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @04:34PM
(#26172092)
But aeronautics engineers can’t fly. However all humans possess the capacity to behave ethically.
We do generally expect a teacher to be able to explain a concept outside of their job, a writer to write a good note or letter, a photographer to take a good photograph when out casually with friends and family. Similarly we’d want people making moral judgement to demonstrate that capacity.
Re:Coronavirus human challenge study gets green light in UK
by StavrosK on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @04:42PM
(#26172178)
Ethicists study ethics. Per your example, I would expect an ethicist to be able to study ethics very well. You don't expect a teacher to know everything, or a writer to always speak with perfect eloquence, or a photographer to always take great photos.
I don't understand why someone who studies ethics should behave better, any more than someone who studies the human musculature to be able to lift more weight.
Re:Coronavirus human challenge study gets green light in UK
by throwaway3699 on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @07:35PM
(#26173905)
You expect some correlation. Even 5%.
Re:Coronavirus human challenge study gets green light in UK
by celticninja on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @06:17PM
(#26173168)
But surely all you could expect is that they consider the ethics of the situation. Not that they always choose the the most ethically correct outcome. After all a writer might just need a shopping list, not a sonnet.
I don't see how that follows. We don't expect our ethicists to behave more ethically any more than we expect our aeronautics engineers to fly.