News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Insecurity in the Jungle (disk) by cperciva on Friday June 03, 2011 @12:33PM (#2616979)
To my mind, the key derivation is the real problem here. A surprisingly large number of secure encryption storage products don't ensure data integrity. Realistic attacks against that vulnerability are feasible but difficult: you'd have to be targeted.

I think the lack of integrity is more important than you're making it sound. There's a lot of situations where a lack of integrity can be exploited to create a lack of privacy too.

But the main reason I mentioned the lack of integrity first is that I needed to mention the lack of HMAC to explain why they had the ridiculous "salted key hash" construct.

If you're going to write an article about how a competitor's encryption is inferior to yours and cast it as a vulnerability report, I'd suggest not recommending your own encryption scheme as the replacement. The scrypt recommendation in this article sticks out like a sore thumb. Virtually nothing uses scrypt.

I think you're misstating what I wrote a bit. I said that scrypt is the state of the art in the field -- which it is -- and that given that Jungle Disk was around before I developed scrypt, they should have used PBKDF2 or bcrypt.

Re:Insecurity in the Jungle (disk) by tptacek on Friday June 03, 2011 @12:38PM (#2617002)
I'd rather geek out about CTR v CBC than harp on the scrypt recommendation. Consider the scrypt thing a friendly style note. You wrote an article about a competitor's insecurities. When you do that, don't recommend they adopt your own cryptosystem unless (like CRI had to do with DPA countermeasures) they have to. Here, it just made you look unnecessarily petty.

What privacy attacks were you thinking of? Call some of them out.

Re:Insecurity in the Jungle (disk) by cperciva on Friday June 03, 2011 @01:31PM (#2617216)
Consider the scrypt thing a friendly style note.

Note taken. :-)

What privacy attacks were you thinking of?

Things like replacing files with malware.

Re:Insecurity in the Jungle (disk) by tptacek on Friday June 03, 2011 @01:33PM (#2617232)
Yeah, we were saying the same thing, I think, but you said it more clearly.