I also disagree that AI researchers are working on boring narrow problems. There are plenty of researchers working on huge open problems like object recognition, speech recognition, reinforcement learning, etc. And they're making great progress too. I think the reason most AI researchers don't talk about making "human-level AI" is that this isn't really a quantifiable goal. There are plenty of things computers can do better than people already (would you want a computer with "human-level" addition and subtraction?). And for just about every specific useful task humans do better than computers, there are a few dozen AI researchers working on it. Why is that not a reasonable approach to the problem?
While a lot of progress is being made in the redefined and inaccurately named field of AI, object recognition and speech recognition are still narrow domains. They are not using general purpose approaches, but instead tweaking and tuning specific algorithms to these areas. In reality, I am not championing for "human-level AI", as I think it would be very difficult to duplicate a human's strengths and deficiencies [3] accurately. Instead, I am saying that we should be encouraging research that produces a general intelligence; software that can recognize and exploit regularities (patterns) in the state spaces of many problem domains, and apply the abstracted knowledge gained from earlier experiences to new domains and problems. Such software would have a tremendous impact on society, assisting us in solving and analyzing many problems and likely leading to an "intelligence explosion" after crossing some threshold at which the software is able to recursively improve itself. [4]
You asked "just about every specific useful task humans do better than computers, there are a few dozen AI researchers working on it. Why is that not a reasonable approach to the problem?" How do we take all these domain specific solutions and get a cohesive general intelligence out of them? I see these domain specific algorithms as being possibly useful to a general intelligence as an optimization to shift some of the load off of the more general purpose algorithms, but I don't see how throwing a bunch of face recognition, path finding, neural network and genetic algorithms into a box would automatically cause a general intelligence to pop out. These research areas seem mostly tangential or supportive to genuine Artificial General Intelligence research.
1. http://www-formal.stanford.edu/jmc/history/dartmouth/dartmouth.html
2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolmogorov_complexity
Don't get me wrong, I'd love to create a general artificial intelligence. It's just not clear to me what that means. In the absence of a good definition of the general problem, I think it's perfectly reasonable to pick an extremely hard specific problem (like visual object recognition), and focus on that, under the assumption that in order to completely solve this specific problem you will end up solving the (undefined) general problem.
"A "true AI" would discover regularities [2], or patterns, in any search space, and exploit these patterns to incrementally improve its ability to navigate the search space." -- Actually this sounds like Eurisko, a heuristic search program that modifies it's own heuristics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurisko
Also, it's worth pointing out that the different techniques used in different subfields of AI are not always that different. There has been some work in creating very general powerful frameworks that explain a lot of specific algorithms, like Markov logic networks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Markov_logic_network which are sufficiently powerful that they subsume all of logic and statistical graphical models (which is to say maybe 90% of all recent machine learning algorithms). With these sorts of general frameworks new algorithms and approaches in one subfield get ported over to other subfields, and there is more interaction then you might think.
But you're right: we don't know much about intelligence nor how it should be embodied on a computer. This is why we should encourage some really smart people to focus on the problem! I sincerely think this is an area that would yield to research. Might take a long time and a lot of brainpower though...
Lenat's Eurisko is pretty cool, and I don't know much about it, but it doesn't sound like Eurisko is as general as is needed.
I'm sure that a lot of researchers in academia have pet theories about how to make it happen, but they need grants. The NSF has funded enough failed AI projects, it's hard for them to justify funding more given the current lack of money in science.
There are probably a lot of people working on AGI on their own, or in startups. I am. But you won't hear much about people like me unless we succeed to some level.
IMO, the field is waiting for its Einstein to come up.
Here's a good but long video that discusses AGI and why it's feasible, aimed at a technical audience. Skip over the introductions at the beginning. Google Video: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-821191370462819511 Higher quality 1GB MPEG4: http://www.archive.org/details/FutureSalon_02_2006 Shorter video on "The Human Importance of the Intelligence Explosion": http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=6114518772001796913 Eliezer Yudkowsky also has some interesting papers at http://yudkowsky.net
Help advance AGI, donate to the Singularity Institute for Artificial Intelligence! http://www.singinst.org/challenge Feel free to email me if you're interested in chatting on these topics.