News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clubhouse Bio Generator by vidarh on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @07:24AM (#26165583)
I spend a good chunk of my time at work evaluating pitchdecks, and even in the crypto space it's notable that most people try to build concepts that insert themselves as a rentseeking central hub even when their idea doesn't in any way require it. Clearly a lot of people see that as the best way of securing their ability to monetise.

But at least for some of those ideas it's clear that they'd have a far greater shot at success if they opened up and created something that allowed more benefits to flow to potential partners, and even to potential competitors, because it'd increase their chance of being the new standard in $field. They might end up with a smaller market share, but of a much larger market.

I'm not saying that will work for everyone, because it won't. But it seems people way too rarely consider if that's even a possibility, because they're from the start putting effort into preventing a decentralised model from working. Then, after they've ruled out a decentralised solution, a whole lot of them add "blockchain" to their pitchdeck after having made blockchain totally pointless by introducing a centralised authority... Sometimes I just want to lock some of these founders in a room and ask them "why?" over and over.

Re:Clubhouse Bio Generator by josephg on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @07:39AM (#26165693)
I have some friends who've done blockchain consulting work for a few years. I've found myself hanging out with them at a lot of blockchain events. I ask those annoying questions a lot, like "why" and "Isn't this just a badly implemented, unscalable mostly centralized system with weak governance?".

Its usually fun (for me) but I never get any good answers. It feels like arguing about the existence of god with believers. My working theory is that young technologists get into blockchain because it seems cool, and its something bigger than themselves to care about. Before long they have lots of friends who are believers too, and asking hard technical questions feels like a threat to their community. So they don't ask, and instead spend years working on technology thats an obvious dead end. (Which isn't to say everything in the field is useless; but about 90% of it almost certainly is.)

Re:Clubhouse Bio Generator by vidarh on Wednesday February 17, 2021 @07:56AM (#26165791)
The irony is that quite a few of these systems could potentially be revolutionary if they were willing to give up enough control. Many of them are centralised because they think it's the best way of making money of it, even though it's compromising their original technical vision and making their use of blockchain meaningless. I think quite a few of those will be crushed when someone dare create decentralised versions of their original idea and they can't respond.

I think we will see some fantastic uses of blockchain eventually, but I worry a very substantial proportion of the people pitching blockchain based ideas today don't even understand that they're missing the point themselves or know they've compromised everything but don't dare pitch the uncompromising decentralised vision.