News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by gaius on Friday June 03, 2011 @09:19AM (#2616202)
I don't think that's true. Find an ordinary user who likes Flash intros on websites, or who likes attention-seeking Flash ads disturbing them while reading an article.

The only thing that Flash is used for that real people (as opposed to marketing twerps) actually like is cheesy little games, and they can be done perfectly well without Flash these days.

Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by MatthewPhillips on Friday June 03, 2011 @09:41AM (#2616283)
Simply not true. Gmail calling is not possibly in HTML/js.

There are a lot of cool websites that use Flash for more than games and video these days. Qwiki won TechCrunch Disrupt last year. Beatlab is a super cool music creation app.

And Flash will likely always be the standard for DRM Video on the web. Being an open standard, HTML5 can never include DRM.

I see Flash's place is as a stopgap for features that haven't been standardized/implemented yet. It does those very well.

Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by daniel02216 on Friday June 03, 2011 @12:09PM (#2616890)
Gmail calling uses Google's own plugin, not Flash. And they just open sourced it and intend for browser makers to integrate it into their browsers. Hopefully it will be possible to do video calling in HTML soon.
Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by evilduck on Friday June 03, 2011 @10:04AM (#2616364)
From a desktop perspective, video streaming is still a marginally more pleasant experience in Flash than in HTML5 equivalents (random position seeking, full screen controls, quality, etc). It may full well be an individual site's deficient/immature HTML5 implementations, I've never been curious enough to investigate in-depth, but I also have yet to experience a better experience in HTML5 that would create an incentive to seek out those implementations over a Flash version if Flash is presented as the default choice.

Flash file uploaders also tend to be more mature and a little smoother to use in general. I'm sure HTML5 will surpass it soon enough, but at present, it's a use of Flash that I don't mind.

Additionally, I somewhat dread the day when annoying and/or malicious advertising makes the switch. At present, blocking Flash is a stupid simple task, a standards based annoyance has the potential to be much harder to avoid.