Or perhaps more likely, they did think about transgender people but their is simply nothing they can do about it because their tool does not have enough available input data to factor this in.
Just like the tool can not know if I have long or short hair based on my voice, it also won't be able to know anything else that has deviated from the average.
Their mistake was just one of labeling. The software was not predicting gender identity, it was predicting biological sex.
Please explain the difference.
> when the researchers probably didn't even think about transgender people at all
This here is the problem, and public discourse has a solution to the word you're seeking: transinclusive.
"-inclusive" succinctly provides a hint on how to be considerate, while being optimistic.
Hate & phobia issues aside.
Edit: Most research begins describing exactly why the research was undertaken.
Re:Who Should Stop Unethical A.I.?
by lordCarbonFiber on Monday February 15, 2021 @08:21PM
(#26149878)
A mistake that a lot of people make when talking about bigotry is assuming it begins and ends with loud angry people yelling slurs. Building a system that genders people based on their voice isn't "inconsiderate" it's just a transphobic thing to do. Systematic biases don't require malice from any individual working within them to perpetuate; but that doesn't make them any less real and doesn't mean that we shouldn't just accept that all tech should also support them.
Re:Who Should Stop Unethical A.I.?
by sillysaurusx on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @12:37AM
(#26151272)
It's surprising you're getting hammered for this sentiment, since as far as I can tell, no sentence is mistaken.
Re:Who Should Stop Unethical A.I.?
by lordCarbonFiber on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @10:21PM
(#26162254)
Say anything positive about trans people on this site and the downvotes come ^_^;;
On the other hand, I think it's legitimate to criticize research that has many obvious bad applications and few obvious good applications.
(Perhaps an important factor is why this research was being done in the first place? Did they build a "reconstruct what a person probably looks like from their voice" just to see if they could, or did they have some real application in mind? For instance, suppose they were working with a group of oceanographers who wanted a system to infer the characteristics of orcas from their whalesong as part of a project to track their migration habits, and the researchers decided to test their system on people first because it's easier and less expensive. If a project was undertaken for a good reason, but it opens the door to a lot of bad applications as an unintentional side-effect, should the researchers get a free pass on the latter?)