News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by zmmmmm on Thursday June 02, 2011 @08:22PM (#2614634)
Why do I suspect Mossberg's statement could be reduced to?

I have yet to test a single [Android phone]

Ok, cheap shot, but I really think he's not actually tried it on high end phones with reasonable flash apps that are designed for mobile use. Yes, if you go to cnn.com which fully expects to be running on a desktop it stutters. It stutters on some desktop computers too. But go to the mobile games sites that specialize in Flash games for phones - and many of them are great.

Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by staunch on Thursday June 02, 2011 @08:45PM (#2614702)
His entire argument for Flash is that you don't have to rewrite your app for different platforms.
Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by zmmmmm on Thursday June 02, 2011 @09:14PM (#2614773)
No. You're mixing in a different definition of "platform" here to include hardware profile. A flash app designed to run well on one mobile device will probably run well on other mobile devices with little or no modification. On the other hand a flash app designed to run well on a desktop probably is not going to run well on mobile hardware. But then probably neither will any app built on any technology that was designed to make use of desktop level hardware.
Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by zmmmmm on Thursday June 02, 2011 @10:22PM (#2614912)
Well, it's interesting to see my comment sink down to negative territory. Here's the exact quote from Narayen in the linked article:

> The value proposition Flash has is that we allow people to author programs once and get them to as many devices as possible

He says "devices", clearly indicating that he is arguing the value proposition is to deploy across multiple phone (or mobile device) platforms, not some kind of write-once-run-anywhere proposition that works across desktop and mobile.

Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by urbanjunkie on Friday June 03, 2011 @05:19AM (#2615665)
He's used the phrase "multiple devices" before, and he's clearly referring to more than mobile phones.

In this interview from last year he states [1]

"The world is emerging where there are multiple devices [...] to access the internet

Mobile devices are certainly a big part of it, tablet devices will be a part of it, televisions and PCs..."

the more these platforms adopt flash, they won't have to do anything else. It will just work"

Seems pretty clear to me.

[1] http://www.flashstreamworks.com/archive.php?post_id=12726539...

Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by jakeludington on Thursday June 02, 2011 @08:33PM (#2614668)
Flash is pretty lousy even on the 4G Android phones. Plenty of browser crashes all over the place. That said, at least Flash support is there.
Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by bradshaw1965 on Thursday June 02, 2011 @09:29PM (#2614803)
...That said, at least Flash support is there.

I hear that argument a lot, but I've never found myself where a kludge of a technology really saved the day. I lump it with the web browser on the Kindle where the idea of having it available is much more interesting then even the desert island use of the tech.

Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by MatthewPhillips on Friday June 03, 2011 @09:44AM (#2616293)
That's because it's not a "kludge of a technology". It works most of the time, doesn't some times, and has bad problems (locking up your browser, crashing, etc.) on the minority of times. A lot of anti-Flash people, for whatever reason, translate the bad occurrences as "blows" or some other hyperbole.
Re:Walt Mossberg Tells Adobe CEO To His Face That Flash Suck... by bradshaw1965 on Friday June 03, 2011 @10:06AM (#2616369)
I've seen some compiled flash air apps that are useful, but we'll just have to disagree on the utility of it in the browser.