You explained the fundamental philosophical divide in software development today. One group sees development as a process of production. They still think of developers as people who produce code. The other group sees software development as a process of problem discovery and definition. Programming is an exploratory learning process that, at its best, refines and condenses human concepts and symbols into concrete representations automated by a computer. In my opinion the latter group will always outperform the former (barring massive resource discrepancies) because they have a more powerful theoretical grip on their activities.