News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by vmception on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:59PM (#26127372)
> otherwise why they are using a Shanghai-based startup for their voice backend platform?

Is there a term for this form of argument? Like where someone makes a rhetorical question after seeding the answer? Its like creating a false dilemma, where one intentionally removes non-binary choices for their own agenda, but its not quite a false dilemma yet, except after someone responds about how weak this form of argument is by presenting second, third and fourth reasons that were outside of the boundaries of the question but inside the boundaries of reality.

Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by darkteflon on Saturday February 13, 2021 @08:34PM (#26128874)
There is huge power in knowing the name of a thing, isn’t there. Reminds me of a Wittgenstein quote: "The limits of my language mean the limits of my world.”
Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by acheron9383 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:11PM (#26127457)
Seems like begging the question, they assume it is a CCP honeypot and then push the false dichotomy with the voice back end? *edit s/video/voice/
Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by 188201 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @09:00PM (#26128992)
I would admit it was actually not a proper form of argument and a constructive way to form a discussion. However, there is a real dilemma right here. If a company is going to use a technology from an adversarial country that could potentially harming oppressed people, it could potentially be a PR disaster.

The bigger question right here is why startup culture works so successfully. The purpose of a VC Startup assumes to create a product to expand the marketshare to the world eventually. And it was based on the assumption of globalization. In a world where it was less polarized to politics opinion and enjoy the economical growth and appreciation of new tech. A entrepreneur who neglect geo-politics could do pretty fine in this environment.

With the rise of sharp power of China, the question is not so straightforward. Hollywood company faced China's influence by banning content that is not favorable to China, in order to get access to China's market. Airline companies were threatened by China to not referring Taiwan as country otherwise a boycott to those airline. If a company just comply to China's request or threat, then they could potentially piss off Taiwan and Hong Kong customers, and potentially losing other countries in the free world if the PR was too bad. However, they don't comply, then they could potentially lose access to China's market. It is difficult to be neutral and not taking side, because of the polarization of both parties. Not taking side was potentially the worst option which would piss off both side because both thinks the company does not stand for their value.

It is just a extension of this underwater war. The take right here is if a startup is intended to be used by the world, the owner may need to be prepared for unintentionally pissing off a potential group of customers because of not understanding sensitive geo-polictics issue.

Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by vmception on Saturday February 13, 2021 @09:12PM (#26129056)
The American and Western market has sensibilities too even if they dont come from the government the user experience is the same. Try disagreeing with Isreali domestic and foreign policy and doing business in any industry in the West, especially Hollywood. You have to censor.

Deciding that China’s gatekeeping is worse just because it comes the government is where we lose a lot of possibility of introspection from people.

Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by 188201 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @09:35PM (#26129164)
On retrospective, is it just another form of this technique? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_(propaganda)
Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by vmception on Sunday February 14, 2021 @01:42AM (#26130211)
This is interesting, glad to see the retrospective, this technique does seem similar
Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by swebs on Saturday February 13, 2021 @08:53PM (#26128957)
I believe the term is called "debate". You're just assuming the question is rhetorical, but I don't think that's true.
Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by Barrin92 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:37PM (#26127190)
>why they are using a Shanghai-based startup for their voice backend platform

because a lot of Chinese companies are really good at voice related services due to the ubiquitous use of it in China. (typing Mandarin is annoying because you have to use pinyin).

Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by dathinab on Saturday February 13, 2021 @09:14PM (#26129068)
> why they are using a Shanghai-based startup

Maybe, because that startup does a good job for an reasonable cost.

> Clubhouse is a honey pot for CCP

No it's a fancy life style app which doesn't care about censorship resistance at all. As far as I know you can be pretty sure that any service operating in China will have backdoors or similar of some form, through potentially only for their Chinese users.

So as long as you don't use a service which explicitly cares about censorship and privacy which also operates in China you shouldn't trust them with any sensitive information at all especially if part of the "conversation" is "in china". I mean I would be seriously surprised if the key-server of e.g. zoom doesn't leak encryption keys for "(partial) in china" conversations to the government.

And coming back to clubhouse while they might seem to be privacy orientated on the first sight they are, as far as I can tell not. They just use "exclusivity" as a way to sell there product and mistaking this "exclusivity" with privacy would be a big mistake.

I mean some of the most common usages of club house are basically a fancy form of a pod-cast "just more exclusive".

> Or prove me wrong

Your argument is as much based on biased assumptions as is mine. So this discussion is pretty far away from any prove in any direction tbh.

Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by approxim8ion on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:15AM (#26130545)
This isn't even a bad faith argument, it's a straight-up conspiracy theory that you can't hope to prove in any meaningful way.
Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by vmception on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:28PM (#26127591)
The CCP has all power over corporate trade in China, and can obtain access to corporate data.

That fact of life is not guiding factor for why corporations create technology, compete for contracts, and make revenue.

And there is a lot of technology there. It is an innovative, high growth, competitive maybe overly competitive, and dense part of the world. Most of which has nothing to do with what's happening on the other side of the Gobi desert. If that is to be your cause, great, because that's going to keep happening, but its a large stretch to make that the sole guiding factor for everyone else that creates or simply uses software from China.

If you are subject to that system, then you should use discretion on Clubhouse, that would really be the entirety of your message.

Re:Clubhouse user IDs, Chatroom IDs are transmitted in plain... by shalmanese on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:24AM (#26130577)
If it was a honeypot, then why block it inside of China? Now they have to break a VPN on top of breaking a voice chat protocol in order to get the real identities of people inside of China.